*NO* ICO 'Shrouded Castle'

[djpretzel]

DJ Pretzel,

I apologize for the inconvience, but it seems that Geocities was having trouble with my file - the MP3 itself was glitchy whenever I uploaded it. I have an alternate file here: This one shouldn't have any glitches in it. Thank you for your understanding.

Joe Bommarito

[DarkCecil13]

Uh, DJP, this isn't ViolentRage's ICO 'Shrouded Castle' information that you posted here in this thread.

[djpretzel]

Uh, DJP, this isn't ViolentRage's ICO 'Shrouded Castle' information that you posted here in this thread.

Fixed - thanks.

[DarkCecil13]

The link simply doesn't work. I've right-clicked and left-clicked both.

[Protricity]

UHHH...
just a thought,

http://www.angelfire.com/retro/aviolentrage/ICO_Shrouded_Castle_OC_ReMix.mp3.

Try removing the period at the end

http://www.angelfire.com/retro/aviolentrage/ICO_Shrouded_Castle_OC_ReMix.mp3

I dont know why I came up with such a crazy idea. Anyway, Review pending.

If you still have Period related problems, no pun intended, contact me for the file.

So anyway,

I really REALLY like the use of the strings and piano.
The melody was changed and in a good way.

Good effort presented, and a VERY good feel to this song.

YES

[Malcos]

I like this, very nicely done. The sounds are fresh, and the drums, while light, fit very well.

YES

[Disco Dan]

Man, that intro was SO anticlimactic. I'm sorry, but I kept listening to this repeated pattern thinking "ok, something's supposed to happen... NOW!" and nothing did. Ok, now strings. Nice. Do something. Ok, now repeat. Ok, then just end. 'Cause heaven forbid we develop or anything. Nah, this is WAY too boring for my tastes. It sounds like the start of a 10 minute epic song, but it seems very unfinished in its current form. Too many unfinished projects on this site as it is.

NO

D

[DarkCecil13]

I had talked to Mr. Bommarito about this mix long ago before he submitted it. I had said that I enjoyed listening to it. The arrangement is well presented, but it's just way to short. There CAN be more, but Mr. Bommarito shows laziness in this aspect. I agree with DiscoDan. Expand.

NO

[Saunders]

Well, it's nice, but it doesn't really do a whole lot. It's a little too simple. The whole time it feels like it's about to go into something a little more complex, I believe this is what Dan and Tom refer to. It just seems like half (or less than half) a song.

Vote: No

[orkybash]

As others have said, it starts off nice but really doesn't go anywhere. I would really like to see this with a little more work put into developing the ideas, because there are some great ones. As it is, though, I found myself tuning this out about halfway through because it kept doing pretty much the same thing over and over, and that's never good.

NO