*NO* Final Fantasy 'Prelude for Piano'

[djpretzel]

We'd definitely need a better recording/better compression using LAME - djp

Artist Name: - CLAY -
Artist Email: sirclay@bellsouth.net
Artist Web: http://www.mp3.com/-clay-/
Song: Final Fantasy - Prelude for Piano
Song URL:
Note: The Prelude is obviously a hard song to attribute given its presence in most of the installments of the game. The game I intended it for was Final Fantasy VI.

[Jivemaster]

Shit, I just reviewed this and then lost my text!! To sum up:

:arrow: Make quality level higher - 160, 192 or variable.
:arrow: Mix too dry, add reverb or delay.... anything!!

If these things are done, I will say yes. It's similar to McVaffe's piano exclusive stuff.

NO

-Jive

[DarkCecil13]

Some decent piano work here. Sounds live to me. Of course, there's no way to pan piano like this without it being synthesized. The piano falls-out too quickly. It needs more presence after the note itself is interrupted by another piano note. As mentioned by DJP and Jivemaster, the encoding is a little sketchy. Re-encode higher, please?

NO

[Malcos]

Nice piano work! But the sustain needs to be held for the last few notes in each bar as well, and a higher quality version would be good as well. If this was done, I would say yes without a doubt. It would be good to see this on OC.

So NO for now.

[Protricity]

Pros:

Interesting and original take on the ever-exhausted prelude

Cons:

Way too short.
Need more skill on the peddle, me thinks.

NO

[orkybash]

Yeah, as others have said, this sounds too dry. Use of the pedal would help a lot here. Also, it ended a bit abruptly, it could have easily gone on for a while longer.

NO

I love this prelude arrangement, though, and I'd highly encourage a resubmit!