*NO* Shadowgate 'Symphony'

[djpretzel]

Shadowgate_Symphony_OC_Remix.mp3, email sub, no other info provided -djp

[Protricity]

The style is continuous. The drumfills are all the same. I would suggest more varried drum fills and perhaps a more intersting drum progression.

This follows the original rather exactly. The bells have a bit of floody release. Notes never change, and finally, its only 2 minutes.

Work on song length, change up the style perhaps, along with the beat and the melody.

NO

[Beatdrop]

Er, wow. This is really really really repetitive. The mixing's bad, the song's generally quite loud, and all of the sounds seem to have come from a very cheap sound module.

NO

[Israfel]

The arrangement here isn't really that bad- it manages to really highlight some of the strengths of the original and the voice leading that's used here is pretty effective.

But I also agree with the comments of the judges:

a bit too repetitive, there's really only one musical idea here that's looped about 3 or 4 times.

the mixing needs work- the drums are perhaps too loud, and the whole mix sounds like either the mids or highs are up a little too much, resulting in a generally abrasive sound.

I'd stick with it though- this sounds like you've got some real talent and just need some more practice.

But for now,
NO

[Vig]

there is....so much clipping....its constant.

NO




Oh, and as for the mix itself, it's short, it repeats, and it maintains the same dynamic level throughout the whole mix.