*NO* Super Mario RPG 'Smithy's Orchestra'

[djpretzel]

Title of remix: Super Mario RPG - Smithy's Orchestra (OCRemix) Remixer name: Blak_Omen
Website: http://www.soundclick.com/blakomen
Email: darketernal_13@hotmail.com

Here is my orchestral take on Battle With Smithy: Part one from SMRPG. I hope you enjoy. A score is available...just to let y'all know. =P



___BLAK OMEN___

[Protricity]

ftp://aripc.dhcp.asu.edu/Upload/2-18 fight against smithy.spc

This is pretty cool. Lots of potential here. Awe damn, its over already...
2 minutes.

I really like this. Aside from the string and flute bends, there ain't much wrong with it... except the length.

2 Minutes simply doesnt cut it for orchistral.

Go for twice the length and resubmit.

NO

[Vig]

it is cool, indeed, but it is also 2:20. while in and of itself that number doesnt mean too much regarding my vote, this mix fails to build, elaborate, expand, change, and descend.

this isnt the radio; let's try for a version for those of us with attention spans.


NO

[GrayLightning]

This is fantastic. String bends however aren't. I completely agree with vig and prot on this one. This is a bit too short as the ideas aren't completely realized here. Great job so far, but please work on this one more, as it feels incomplete right now. I think this would get a fast-track status if you decided to resubmit.

a sad NO, for now

[Malcos]

This sounds great, but I agree with what Vigilante said about it being like a radio mix, but shorter! This is something that could be really absorbing if it were longer.

There are 3 types of NO's

1. No, do something else.
2. No, fix this up.
3. No we want more.

This is the 3rd type. More!

NO