*NO* Silent Hill 'Music Room Remix'

[djpretzel]

Well, the Angelfire Link was dead within minutes, don't know which terms of use exactly I'm supposed to have violated, but what the hell. I had mercy and renamed the thing to Music Room, makes more sense anyway. ;)



Regards,


Eraxel

[Protricity]

Sorta simple and boring. Rather environmental. Boring only cause this is pretty much how the original sounds. Just a lot of 1/1 notes with basic chord changes. Way short. This could be mucho developed.

NO

[The wingless]

I like it. It's subtle where the original was garish, somber where the original was abrasive. I do have to agree with Protee that this could have been developed a whole lot more (Russel of the Cox Clan comes to mind) but as it stands right now, it's a very smooth little haunt for the ears. Good, with the potential to be greater, which is alright in my book.

YES

[Vig]

this seriously lacks development. it's not complete.

add more.

NO

[GrayLightning]

Very nice. Along with the other comments already made, I would say this mix needs to be explored in greater detail. There is a lot of solid foundation and untapped possibilities here that makes this worth coming back to. I would use a touch less reverb also.

Close one, I could go either yes or no on this one. Borderline No. Expand on it compositionally and instrumentally and this could be far better.

[danny B]

Like the Viggy said, underdeveloped. Needs more attention to SQ basics, like EQ and compression, and some kind of arrangement diversity to keep it from total monotony. Sounds like WIP v 0.5. Finish 'er on up, send 'er on back.

NO

-D