*NO* Unreal Tournament 'Progressive Phantom'

[djpretzel]

Email sub file UT_ProggresivePhantom_OC_ReMix.mp3 - djp


Song: Phantom
Game; Unreal Tournament
Autor: Arkano

[Liontamer]

Flat and generic, not unlike many fashion show models. Flat/generic sounds all around, and the percussion in particular is weak. The decently used male vox at 2:05 was certainly a cool idea. Whatever spastic synth came in at 3:13 should have been left out, and its use right near the close of the track crudded the ending. Whatever the arrangement structure could have had going for it was underminded by the sounds. "Bleh" is my honest reaction. Unsalvageable.

NO

[Malcos]

This mix has taken an UT track that was quite a hard one and just softened it up a lot. Very weak and the percussion was extremely soft. For me, this just doesn't suit the track or the game.

NO

[GrayLightning]

I didn't think it was as bad as the prior votes. It's average in my book. There's nothing terribly wrong here, but there's nothing that stands out.

The appearance of the male voice until the end was definitely the strongest section of the mix.

Decent, but there's not enough hooks, complexity or uniqueness. Sorry, but it's a NO from me.

[Vig]

if i recall, the UT original was already fairly complex, with pretty good sound quality. i think a few things that stand out are the perc sfx, the vox was also good. unfortunately the arrangement was not particularly directed, leaving the piece forgettable. just doesnt have anything over the original


NO