*NO* Ys 3 'The Boy Who Had Wings'

[Liontamer]

Hi, i'm Mathieu DALI i do game remixes since long time but i never share my work. so i'd like to be juged by specialists like you thanks
The Nickname i use is Flamex

The track i'd like to submit is a remix of "Y's III - Wanderers from Ys" the track is called : "The Boy who had Wings"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ys_III:_Wanderers_from_Ys

I hope to have a positive return :) !!!

---------------------------------------------------------------

Ys III - "The Boy Who Had Wings" (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gzdVLq34iDw)

Cool to hear something like Ys III get some love. We definitely need more Falcom stuff. This does get a bit more expansive with the original, but the structure is pretty verbatim, so you need even more personalization to make this arrangement stand apart as unique compared to the original. That's also hard to do when your arrangement is the same name as the original.

The mixing/production also needed work. It sounds like most of the higher frequencies got cut out, and everything except for the leads sounds really far away in the soundscape.

Keep at it.

NO

[DarkeSword]

This sounds a lot like a sound upgrade of the original. There are some background rhythmic changes but for the most part this follows the original though.

I didn't really have a problem with the production; it actually sounds like some good shmup dance music. Pretty awesome energy.

I'd like to hear more from you; hopefully pieces with more arrangement and riffing. NO

[OA]

i think the production is fine as well, I'm not sure if Larry's listening setup was messed up or something. Production was over the bar in my estimation.

However, the arrangement is exactly the same as the original, and basically it's a very nice sounding audio upgrade. I definitely enjoyed the track, but there was almost no recognizable arrangement to the source.

no