PDA

View Full Version : *NO* Mega Man X 'Red Nostalgia v2.0'


Antonio Pizza
11-27-2002, 08:31 PM
You say to mail you if it's been a month or two since a mix was
submitted, so here I am.

Red Nostalgia v. 2 was submitted by myself in September or early
October, as I recall, maybe earlier, and I have seen no sign of it. The address it can be DL'd from is .
I do not ask that you evaluate it immediately, just making sure it's
somewhere on the queue (I received a confirmation mail when I submitted
it first). I'd also understand if there is some delay in evaluating it
due to the finnicky nature of the geocities page (much over 4 meg, which is
about the size of RN, per hour and I exceed allotted bandwidth and the site
drops for a while). If it's on the queue, fine, I trust you'll get to it in
due time (although an e-mail stating as much would not be unwelcome),
otherwise getting to it within a month or so would be nice. And if my track
record is against me here, I assure you this one isn't at all as repetitive as
Hair's Breadth. Short, perhaps, but not repetitive.

- seanstar

Protricity
11-27-2002, 11:15 PM
Cant get the file. Anyone wanna help out?

Review pending
Pros:
Nice reexpression of these classic themes.


Cons:
It sounds like 2 different songs stuck together
The composition sounds weak and hollow.


Im really not sure about this mix. Although I dont much care for it, I am also very tired. I'll let it sit in my mind for a while, listen to it a few more times, etc.

Review later


Review NOW

The composition really lacks, Im gonna have to go with a NO

Antonio Pizza
11-29-2002, 07:02 PM
I'm not feelin' this one. I don't care for the samples. I do like the tempo changes and segues, but I'd find some better samples. They just don't fit well with me. No.

Malcos
11-29-2002, 09:07 PM
The arrangement is ok, but the tempo changes are not to my taste at all. There is a lot of variety in the mix, but the sounds are so General Midi soundset, and the percussion could be a lot more defined.

NO

Saunders
11-30-2002, 03:08 AM
I have .mid's that sound better than this (sample wise). The arrangement is.. well it's not horrible I think. Try sprucing this up with some tasty soundfonts or samples, anything if you can get it sounding less like a .mid file. I like Zero's theme and to hear it not be done justice breaks my heart. http://remix.overclocked.org/phpBB2/images/smiles/icon_cry.gif

Vote: No

m68030
12-13-2002, 09:55 PM
shouldn't this be locked? :P