[sggod89]

I suppose I am quite happy, but I assume everyone else is just as happy with the amount of remixes! Tho it did make the voting process much longer than usual haha

It was a great round. I listen to everyone's remix a few times and gave you each feedback. Voting was really tough, but my first place choice really knocked it out of the park for me (and you'll know who you are shortly!).

[evktalo]

Awesome turnout, hope I manage to throw in a vote.

--Eino

[Dj Mokram]

So many entries this time around. T'was a great round folks.
Oh, and after voting I noticed that the member profiles are back.
Maybe change is on the way for TS.

Let's hope for many more awesome PRCs like this one.

[Trism]

Originally Posted by Dj Mokram

So many entries this time around. T'was a great round folks.
Oh, and after voting I noticed that the member profiles are back.
Maybe change is on the way for TS.

Let's hope for many more awesome PRCs like this one.

Well I've got a taste for it now, so I'll be entering as often as possible

[Bundeslang]

It's results time.
The votes are in.

Total number of mixes - 8
Total number of votes - 8

Maximum Score - 27.

Sggod89 did a bonus mix, I gave it one point bonus because it doesn't matter.

Chickenwarlord received the last place wooden spoon. with 4 points.

Obtuse did well and received several points by several voters, the total of 6 is good for sixth place.

Meccaneer finished fifth, claiming 8 points.

Trism did a good job as well, ending fourth, with 9 points.

Sir Nuts claimed 14 points, which is a strong third position.

Hoboka was close to win, but 15 points is worth a second place.

And the winner is DjMokram with 16 points.


Congratulations DjMokram, you are the winner. It was a very close, and 16 points is not even close to the maximum 27 points. That is a very positive sign, and all the songs scored at least one point. Great job everyone and I hope to have more PRC's like this one.

DjMokram, you may select the next source for PRC219. Send your source to me by PM, other options are PM me @ ThaSauce or by e-mailing to bambombim@gmail.com (I prefer a PM @Ocremix). Do that as soon as you can, but before Friday.

Remember to select a source with a MID file added. You may also select a source without a MID, but then you must provide a second source with a MID file.

You may select any source from any game, as long as it doesn't have an Overclocked Remix and it hasn't been on PRC before. Check it at the list:
http://sites.google.com/site/bambombim/prc
http://bambombim.googlepages.com/PRCRemixList.doc (also downloadable via the link above).


You can find the votes with comments here:
http://compo.thasauce.net/votes/index/PRC218

[evktalo]

I didn't manage to even listen to each of the tracks in time, but here's a little something about each track:

Hoboka - Disputed Perspectives: Creative and interpretive, successful! Very nice slowdown. I also like the use of the fake sax.

DjMokram - Spontaneous Combustion: Impressive variety of variations, and also very good, varied sound and production.

Sir NutS - Agressive Parasite: Hard-hitting beat, and good sound throughout the track. Some of the rhythms of the keyboard part in just after the midpoint of the piece isn't as groovy as it could be, but it's a good idea and close! Overall it's a solid dance piece, with good additional lead writing.

Trism - Lost Sight: Impressive PRC debut! Like many others in their votes, I too took notice of the ambient qualities this piece had and enjoyed it greatly. Those first place votes were not undeserved!

Meccaneer - Temporal Perspective: I loved the beat! Overall it's a bit too long, and the piano sound gets a little grating. Good ideas in there in any case, could stands some editing!

Obtuse - Hidden Identity: Nice piece of electronica, with an excellent sonic palette. The lead that enters has around 00:18 or so has a problem with its slow attack I think, which makes it sound messy rhythmically. The clap sound is a bit exposed, mixed a bit high and, I guess it's a bit cheap to carry the beat completely. The basic idea of the beat works however, I could stand to hear more variation and sophistication in the writing. The bird sounds fit in so well I didn't even notice them the first time I listened to it! I like also how it builds up, a little slowly, and it's a little long perhaps, but there are a lot of ideas.

Mitochondrial Groove - Chickenwarlord: The faster pace does stand out. The "midi default" piano in the beginning is pretty stiff, but there's much more attention to sound overall. There are some interesting explorations especially in the middle. Though they don't fully fit together with the source in my opinion, they have enjoyable stuff in there and could fit better with some work.

Parasitic Reave - sggod89: The guitar and rock/metal drums make this piece stand out. The synth compartment is also very well done, starting with the slightly distorted bell/electric piano in the beginning. Very moody! The tempo picks up in just the right moment. Really good change-up! The organ lead is also very fitting for the part. Good structure too.

If I had made a track this round, I would probably called it Adjective Substantive. I mean seriously, look at all the track names of this round. :D

edit: Oh, and looks like my vote - 1st: Dj Morkam, 2nd: Trism and 3rd: Hoboka - wouldn't have affected the outcome.

--Eino

[Trism]

Wow 4th place! I am totally shocked at being voted 1st place twice, I honestly thought my entry was the weakest of all of them. Massive thanks for all the feedback; I'll try and put it to good use for the next entry

[HoboKa]

Well, nearly tied to first place isn't bad - really wanted to choose the next compo source damnit. lol

O well, this compo was real fun, cya guys next round (and expect some heavy competition >:3)