[Thin Crust]

So I heard this song

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OyjTDiNWT0k

And I thought to myself, would it be possible for submissions to be passed mostly on the comedic effect alone?

[Liontamer]

Originally Posted by Thin Crust

So I heard this song

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OyjTDiNWT0k

And I thought to myself, would it be possible for submissions to be passed mostly on the comedic effect alone?

It's up to floss to submit it, not that I have my judge-hat on. That opening FL Slayer-style guitar synth isn't the strongest opening, but it's brief.

Just clarifying -- because your question makes an implication -- there's no different bar based on whether a song's funny or not. It could be hilarious, but if the arrangement isn't interpretive enough or the production is weak, it wouldn't pass.

[Gollgagh]

examples of hilarious songs would be hyadain's FF4 and SMW remixes

[Blue Magic]

Just out of curiosity, is there a running total on the number of remixes that have been submitted to OCR? I know there's around 2200 remixes that have been posted, but out of what?

[KyleJCrb]

Originally Posted by Liontamer

It's up to floss to submit it, not that I have my judge-hat on. That opening FL Slayer-style guitar synth isn't the strongest opening, but it's brief.

Just clarifying -- because your question makes an implication -- there's no different bar based on whether a song's funny or not. It could be hilarious, but if the arrangement isn't interpretive enough or the production is weak, it wouldn't pass.

The CD version uses real guitar and sounds much better overall anyway.

HOWEVER, I talked to brentalfloss about OCR some time ago and he's not really interested in submitting more songs beyond what he already has, sadly.

[Liontamer]

Originally Posted by KyleJCrb

HOWEVER, I talked to brentalfloss about OCR some time ago and he's not really interested in submitting more songs, sadly.

Yeah, Deia talked to him too at a con, MAGFest 10 I think, and he thought his comedic mixes didn't fit the site. I think she tried to tell him that's not the case, but hey, gotta let a brother know again!

No hate if Brent simply doesn't want to submit anything or doesn't care, as it's his prerogative, and he's always been great on a personal level too. But everyone SHOULD know that as long as an arrangement is substantially interpretive and reasonably well-produced, it's not disqualified or scrutinized extra for being a comedy track.

[SonicThHedgog]

For Disjointed chemicals you guys where asking for a 192k render

I pm'd the same thing to Emunator


http://tindeck.com/listen/rkvm

[Liontamer]

Originally Posted by SonicThHedgog

For Disjointed chemicals you guys where asking for a 192k render

I pm'd the same thing to Emunator


http://tindeck.com/listen/rkvm

Got it. Did you want to still use SonicThHedgog as your ReMixer name, BTW? I noticed you're using Aires and Air3s a lot, so I wasn't sure if you're trying to move to a new artist name now. Let me know if you need a change for your ReMixer and/or forum name and I can do that if you need.

[SonicThHedgog]

Originally Posted by Liontamer

Got it. Did you want to still use SonicThHedgog as your ReMixer name, BTW? I noticed you're using Aires and Air3s a lot, so I wasn't sure if you're trying to move to a new artist name now. Let me know if you need a change for your ReMixer and/or forum name and I can do that if you need.

Yes "Air3s" as my mixer name would be excellent!

[Liontamer]

Originally Posted by SonicThHedgog

Yes "Air3s" as my mixer name would be excellent!

Do you want that for your forum name as well, or are you keeping it as is?