ReMix: Metroid Prime 'Samus's Lonesome Waltz'
- Game: Metroid Prime (Nintendo, 2002, GCN)
- ReMixer(s): blackguitar
- Composer(s): Kenji Yamamoto (I), Koichi Kyuma
- Song(s): 'Menu Select'
- Posted: 2010-05-01, evaluated by the judges
Newcomer blackguitar writes:
"This remix had been planned and begun nearly six years ago when I was making my first experiences with software synthesizers. The actual mix was now made from scratch again. The three main parts of the melody are subject to differ each time they appear in order to remain interesting, although I like the natural catchiness of the tune. When I played the game, I liked the constant feeling of being lonely against the hordes of enemies. In my opinion is this what the melody delivers. Nothing could sound more tragic like a heavy metal ballad, so here is my remix."
Been awhile since we had some Metroid Prime action - now Shariq's mellower, hybrid electronic arrangement from 2004 has some rock/metal company. Before I say anything else, look at how positive Jesse was - I almost think he must have been "self-medicated" at the time:
"You've got a distinct Opeth-type thing going on here with the acoustic intro leading into metal. Awesome writing in terms of melodic expansion and interpretation. Right off the bat I dig that you took the melody for your own after the initial hook. The arrangement just continues up and away managing to escalate and escalate and never get boring. I'm amazed at the energy that is sustained.
On the technical end, this is easily the slickest metal production we have on OCRemix. The mixing is great, the guitars sound great. If I must complain about something, the kick sounds just a bit papery, even for the genre. I'd dip out a little bit at 1kHz and maybe boost a bit around 3kHz. Sounds like you used a Beta52 perhaps just a bit too close to the head. The other thing is that I might like to hear a bit more reverb on the snare. But really these things are just nitpicks."
Other judges didn't necessarily agree that the mix had impeccable and/or superior production, but were unanimous about the arrangement and overall execution. Vinnie writes:
"I really love this, there's a ton of variety within what is a pretty basic source. There really aren't a lot of original sections here - almost all of this uses source - but every iteration handles the source differently. And then what is original is seamlessly led into. Love that acoustic intro that adds some Spanish flair that I would have never expected. A very well-crafted, enjoyable arrangement.
While a great production, I don't know if I'd go as far as saying the best either. Those rhythm guitars could be more pushed back and muted to give some breathing room. But that starts to get into personal taste."
Intelligent & creative arrangement, excellent execution, unique source, and pretty damn solid production all adds up to a really well-recieved debut mix that should get some serious attention. Hopefully the artist follows up with more, as this is a very promising introduction!
- lurid on February 3, 2011
- WesternZypher on November 7, 2010
10 out of 10!
- ddavis1979 on October 9, 2010
- JaDE ARaN HaRuNo on June 18, 2010
Metroidfan10;672759 wrote: Sick remix. When I saw another Metroid Prime remix, I wasn't expecting the title sequence.
Really?
..... Really? You weren't expecting the title theme? It's probably the best track (closely followed by Phendrana drifts) that is original to the game.
Yup, this is good. Granted, I have listened to the metroid metal remixes and countless youtube covers, but this is fantastic if for nothing else than having that awesome intro. Yup, nothing else constructive to say other than some fanboyism.
- Master_Yoshi on May 26, 2010
Good arrangement, very nice guitar playing, smooth production. It all comes together to form a very enjoyable remix. Well done.
- Martin Penwald on May 20, 2010
In short, this is one of those tracks that makes me hold OCR so highly.
- Daemon Gildas on May 17, 2010
- Vidilian on May 11, 2010
- dfcentre on May 9, 2010
- Djinn on May 7, 2010

Discussion: Latest 15 comments/reviews; view the