Jump to content

PROTO·DOME   Members

  • Posts

    1,684
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by PROTO·DOME

  1. As in key or chord?

    If it's key you're on about then no, not unless you're playing live; different keys are difficult for different instruments.

    I'm sure it won't even matter to someone with perfect pitch, really.

    However if it's chords you're on about then yes, it matters a lot.

    EDIT -

    Bah, you all covered it anyway. Whatever. This can stand as a testament to me knowing what I'm on about.

  2. Yeah man, definitely digging this. Listening through laptop speakers, so I can't really comment on production. Wasn't the biggest fan of that trumpet at the end, most definitely needs a mellower mute trumpet IMHO, but excellent rhodes playing and lovely chords.

  3. Dubstep is a strangely attractive girl who you wouldn't exactly date long term or, god forbid, bring home to meet your parents, but you totally would and it would totally hit the spot. Unfortunately this chick, whilst pretty dirty and sporting a wonderfully aggressive personality to match, just has, to break the analogy I had going, criminally weak drums.

    Anyway, top stuff on the mixpost dude, looking forward to seeing what you come out with.

  4. I'll believe it you when you show me a song where you have successfully done it.
    What? I think you might be missing the point.

    I've successfully translated guitar parts from mind to MIDI before, doesn't mean it sounds any good, that's the point.

    You can't write off an instrument as 'pointless to learn' just because it's easier to recreate using MIDI.

    I'll believe you can substitute MIDI controlled piano with real piano when you have successfully done it. Go listen to some expressive classical or jazz piano; realise this isn't actually easy whatsoever.

  5. Guitar is hard to sequence. :roll:
    Yeah, but it's the same principle.

    (It's also a pretty naff reason to choose an instrument.)

    Piano will always sound best live, you can never quite capture that with pre-recorded samples, no matter how great they are or the techniques used.

    You can't go out and perform a MIDI set on a live piano.

×
×
  • Create New...