Jump to content

Popping in recording


CSmith
 Share

Recommended Posts

I'm trying to record my piano into the computer through the line in and I'm getting popping in the sound.

It's a Roland digital piano and I'm using the 1/4" jacks and using adapters to convert to a stereo mini plug. I'm using Goldwave to record.

After I record something I have to maximize the volume to be able to hear it. I thought that might be causing clipping, but the readout is showing around -20db as the peak, and the popping can happen in quieter sections too. So I lowered the volume on the line in and set maximize to a max of -10db (since it was at 0 before) and recorded like usual. The result was that the peak volume didn't get over around -35db, but the popping was still there. And the popping isn't at a regular interval, and if I just press record and don't play anything there's a very small amount of hiss but no popping.

Also, possibly related, but when I try to record my electronic drumset, the sond generally distorts if there's a lot going on. I was wondering if maybe this has to do with the wide range of frequencies I'm pushing through all at once. Can a computer soundcard's line in not take that much?

Should I get an external sound card (USB or Firewire)?

I hope someone knows what's going on.

Also, my card is a Xonar D2X, I'm running Windows 7 with 4 gigs of RAM.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The line in input on most built-in soundcards is so so very bad.

If you are serious about recording anything, invest in a dedicated external soundcard. The level is so low because the input impedence of the line input is probably nowhere near matched to your keyboards output = horrible low level sound.

Firewire is better but USB is cheaper. For just recording one or two channels though there's no real reason to go firewire.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks Fishy. I suspected that might be the problem, as when I was into recording before I remembered someone saying line in wasn't very good for it.

I messed around in my options and got rid of the click in my recording. Not sure what did it. If I maximize the sound and apply a hiss reduction filter it actually sounds pretty good, but I'm definitely looking into an external soundcard.

What do you think of the Yamaha Audiogram 6? Ideally I want two sets of stereo inputs, one for my keyboard and one for my drums. I have a condenser mic and cable along with a small mixer back at my parents' house, but from the pictures of the Audiogram it looks like the connector is different. I haven't recorded in so long I forgot almost everything I ever knew (which wasn't much to begin with!), but I definitely want something that will work with the gear I already have. And since I can't seem to find something inexpensive that has 4 1/4" inputs along with 2 MIDI in/out ports, I figure for MIDI I can just get a Midisport 2x2 or something. My computer has like 5 free USB ports at the moment.

I just don't want something low quality, and at the same time I'm nowhere near the level of needing professional-level gear and rackmount units and billions of cables running everywhere.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You can get one of Native Instruments's audio interfaces, I have the Audio Kontrol 1 but it might be too expensive if all you want is piano recording. I got it because it included a free Guitar Rig 4 Pro voucher, but since you're not doing guitars you should go with one of their simpler interfaces (unless you feel like spending $200).

www.nativeinstruments.com

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...