Jump to content

Currently in the Judging Process (updated May 31, 2022)


Liontamer
 Share

Recommended Posts

For frequently asked questions, visit the Judges Panel FAQ at the OCRWiki.

This is an informal service to give submitting artists and the public an idea of what's currently going through the judges panel so that anyone can see if a particular submission is there and if it's been evaluated.

This post is updated as the panel receives more mixes to judge and is kept as up to date as possible. Please note that the judges (NOT djpretzel) update this post, and they do not know where any one submission is beyond the panel; however, any submitting artist is welcome to message a judge and ask about their submission if this post hasn't been updated.

Submissions placed on the judges panel are treated as completed works and judged as-is. However, if you need to revise an arrangement after it has been submitted, please inform the Head Submissions Evaluator of a revision (preferably by replying to your original submission email). Keep in mind that this may delay the evaluation process. Minor fixes that do not alter the arrangement itself (e.g. eliminating clipping, new encoding, fading out a track with an abrupt cutoff) are always acceptable.

If your submission doesn't appear here, you received an auto-confirmation letter, and you DIDN'T receive a direct rejection letter, don't worry - the queue in the submissions inbox is very large, so it could take anywhere from several weeks to several months for OCR to initially review your submission and decide to either:

  • 1) Immediately accept with sent direct acceptance letter (NOT listed in To Be Posted list below)
  • 2) Forward to the panel for voting with sent panel evaluation letter (most often)
  • 3) Immediately reject with sent direct rejection letter

Visit the Judges Panel FAQ for more information.

If no auto-confirmation letter was ever received after the submission was emailed, then it is very unlikely it reached the submissions inbox. Submissions must be sent to submissions@ocremix.org. If a confirmation was received, you didn't receive a direct rejection letter, your mix was submitted before the "Mixes subbed prior to" date listed at the beginning of this thread, and STILL doesn't show up on this post or the site, give the submission information to any one of the judges and they can decide whether or not to forward it to the panel; i.e., fall-through it, although nowadays rarely does a submission "fall through the cracks."

Remember, if you received an form rejection letter, your submission will not be evaluated by the panel.

Judges:

  • Chimpazilla
  • DarkeSword
  • DarkSim
  • Emunator - Lead Submissions Evaluator
  • Gario
  • Jordi Storm
  • Liontamer - Head Submissions Evaluator (PM/email issues to Larry)
  • MindWanderer
  • prophetik music
  • Rexy
  • Sir_NutS
  • XPRTNovice
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 6 years later...

Recently overheard in #ocrjudges:

[7:22 PM] djpretzel: @Liontamer aight that means we're good to go on Rebecca's Xenogears mix, but we need to use/encode/tag the WAV above
[7:22 PM] djpretzel: which represents the collected efforts of Bev & I to address the issues
[7:22 PM] djpretzel: took me way too long, BUT it's a very interesting, complex piece that I think deserves the fixes for its final form
[7:31 PM] Rexy: xenogears?  but the track we fixed was ff9 
[7:34 PM] Gario: LAWL
[7:34 PM] Gario: er, lawl
[7:38 PM] Liontamer: same difference
[7:38 PM] djpretzel: heh
[7:38 PM] djpretzel: okay, ff9 it is!

Mixes subbed prior to September 22, 2021 on the panel.
If you submitted a mix on or after this date, your mix is still in the submissions inbox and will not appear on this page.

- TO BE POSTED - approved by the judges

All YES decisions are subject to change until the mix is posted.
Judges Decisions threads for these mixes are not available until the mix is posted.
NOTE: Submissions that were accepted by email reply (and have bypassed the judges panel) are NOT listed here, but we DO have them.

(2015/12/22) Tomb Raider "Tomb Raider Suite"
(2016/05/20) Super Mario Galaxy "B&M"
(2019/05/14) Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword "Transformation"
(2020/04/03) Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword "The Beginning"
(2020/08/24) Aquaria "Immemorial Waters"
(2020/11/03) Amnesia: The Dark Descent "The Shadow"
(2020/11/16) Lyle in Cube Sector "Gimme Back My Cat"
(2020/11/21) Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door "Qfwfq's Origin of Birds"
(2020/12/20) Command & Conquer: Tiberian Sun "Hypervigilance"
(2021/01/09) Final Fantasy 10 "Sprouting Omens"
(2021/02/06) Xenogears, NiGHTS into dreams... & Tales of Innocence "Semper Saltare"
(2021/07/05) Octopath Traveler "At Finis Gate"
(2021/09/27) Terranigma "Ahh!! The Zombies Ate John Carpenter!"
(2021/09/28) Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword "Songs of Skies"
(2022/04/16) Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Red Rescue Team "Cowboy" *RESUB*
(2022/05/13) F-Zero "When Your Mom Mistakes Captain Falcon for Captain America Again" *RESUB*


- TO BE POSTED - conditional on Encoding

These mixes are on hold until we get a WAV or 192kbps/VBR1 quality encoding, and/or a sampling rate of 44.1kHz, from the ReMixer.
The bitrate or sampling rate of the copy the judges currently have is either too high or too low.
If your mix is listed here and you are unsure why or you have sent an updated version and we have not gotten back to you, please contact a judge.

none

- TO BE POSTED - conditional on Production

These mixes are on hold until we get fixes from the ReMixer.
If your mix is listed here and you are unsure why or you have sent an updated version and we have not gotten back to you, please contact a judge.

none

- TO BE POSTED - conditional (Other)

These mixes are on hold for other reasons.
If your mix is listed here and you are unsure why or you have sent an updated version and we have not gotten back to you, please contact a judge.

(2013/02/10) Cryamore "A True Pioneer" - awaiting game completion/verification of in-game usage

- TO BE POSTED - Project Mixes

These mixes are from in-progress Album Projects and are on hold for the time being.

(2011/12/01) Lufia 2 'Of Twin Compasses'
(2012/04/10) Lufia 2 'Hello, Goodbye' *FALLTHROUGH* *RESUB*
(2012/06/03) Banjo-Kazooie 'No Honey, No Cry'
(2013/01/19) Lufia 2 'Excerion Dives Under'
(2013/04/04) Final Fantasy 3 'An Energy Called Hope'
(2013/04/26) Lufia 2 'Step to the Journey'
(2014/01/19) Super Mario RPG & Dr. Mario 'Chill Out, Smithy'
(2014/04/23) Lufia 2 'Fight for Their Lives'
(2015/11/23) Final Fantasy 3 'Ur Town' *RESUB*
(2016/09/14) Final Fantasy 8 'The Oscar Goes to Laguna LOIRE' *RESUB*
(2017/01/22) Final Fantasy 3 'Belly of the Beast'
(2017/06/26) Castlevania 3 'Theme for Trevor Belmont'
(2018/04/21) Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow 'Hell Is Empty'
(2019/05/24) Lufia 2 'Toccata and Fugue in Dreams'
(2020/02/24) Castlevania: Order of Ecclesia "Volaticus"
(2020/05/02) Banjo-Kazooie "The Oxidation of HMS Marimba"
(2020/10/01) Final Fantasy 3 "Dank Crystals"
(2020/12/05) Final Fantasy 3 "Surfing Fantasy 2" *RESUB*
(2021/01/13) Final Fantasy 3 "The Curtain Is Drawn"


- RECENTLY REJECTED

These mixes have been rejected recently. The decision threads can be found in Judges Decisions.

Ape Escape & Bomberman Hero "Re:Dial (But When the Phone Rings, Let the Monkey Answer)"
Super Mario Bros. 2 "Subcon on Mushrooms"
Batman "Epic Orchestral Arrangement"
Mega Man 3 "The Spark Is Gone"
Pokémon Black Version "Gateway to a Promise"
Mario Kart 64 "Toad's Nightride"
Sonic Advance "That's No Egg"
Punch-Out!! "The Good, the Bad, and the Punched in the Face"
Dragon Warrior 3 "Rest and Relaxation"
Kingdom Hearts: Birth by Sleep "Dismiss (Chinese Mix)"
Super Castlevania 4 "Whip of Justice"
Touhou Eiyashou: Imperishable Night "Stirring an Autumn Moon ~ Mooned Insect Orchestral Arrangement"
Splatoon 2 "Exodus (The Endless Harvest)"
Final Fantasy 3 "Searching for the Dark"
Pokémon Gold Version "Beacon of Hope"
Human Race "The Human Race (BeeZerk Mix)"
F-Zero "When Your Mom Mistakes Captain Falcon for Captain America Again"
Phantasy Star 2 "Orchestral Arrangement"
Final Fantasy 7 "Holding My Thoughts in My Heart"
Star Fox 64 "Distant Region"
Secret of Mana "National Scar"
Return of Ishtar "Ishtar's Embrace"

- TO BE JUDGED

These mixes have been moved from the submissions inbox to the judges' queue and are in the process of being judged.

2020/02 - Path of Exile "Tessa of the Sea"
2020/04 - Valkyrie Profile "Take a Flight"
2020/05 - Animal Crossing: New Horizons "Together Again"
2020/08 - Final Fantasy 7 Remake "A Broken Waltz"
2020/09 - Command & Conquer: Tiberian Sun "Lone Trooper"
2020/12 - Fire Emblem: Genealogy of the Holy War "Reunion"
2020/12 - Gradius "Nemesis Mix"
2021/01 - Fall Guys: Ultimate Knockout "Shred 'n' Slip"
2021/01 - Final Fantasy 9 "It's an Ambush"
2021/01 - Golden Axe "A Golden Axe Journey" *FALLTHROUGH*
2021/01 - Golden Sun "Mercurial Mechanisms" *FALLTHROUGH*
2021/02 - Final Fantasy 7 "Hear Her Cries"
2021/02 - Golden Sun "Isaac's Only Shot"
2021/03 - Undertale "Heartache (Charlie Atom Mix)"
2021/05 - Metal Gear Solid "Solid"
2021/06 - Dragon Warrior 4 "Twisted Sisterz"
2021/06 - Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2 "Roof Is on Fire" *RESUB*
2021/07 - Half-Life 2 "Orwellian"
2021/07 - Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time "Temple of Time: Chant & Carillon"
2021/07 - Metroid Fusion "Serene Spacefish"
2021/07 - Persona 4 "I Like (Your Affection)"
2021/07 - Shin Megami Tensei "Digital Devil Puzzle"
2021/08 - Jet Force Gemini "Dance of the Ant Spawn"
2021/09 - Dissidia: Final Fantasy "Reditus Solis"
2021/09 - Golden Sun "Circles in the Sand"
2021/09 - Skies of Arcadia "Arcadia Legends"
2021/10 - Castlevania: Symphony of the Night "A Lullaby"
2021/10 - Final Fantasy 8 "The Infested Arena" *PROJECT*
2021/10 - Hollow Knight "Hallownest Below the Wastes"
2021/10 - Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword "Songs of Spirit"
2021/10 - Mega Man Zero 4 "Frente en Alto"
2021/11 - Castlevania "Dracula's Tears"
2021/11 - Celeste "Courage in the Dark"
2021/11 - Dark Souls 2 "Majules"
2021/11 - Fire Emblem: Genealogy of the Holy War "Lovers' Quarrel"
2021/11 - House of the Dead: Overkill "The Good, the Sweet, and the Sour"
2021/11 - Pokémon Sapphire Version "Rainy Horizon"
2021/11 - Super Mario Sunshine "Love on Noki Beach"
2021/11 - Super Metroid "Event Horizon"
2021/12 - Dragon Warrior 2 "Epic Footsteps" *RESUB*
2021/12 - Final Fantasy 6 "Jumped in the Serpent Trench"
2021/01 - Golden Axe "A Golden Axe Journey" *FALLTHROUGH*
2021/01 - Golden Sun "Mercurial Mechanisms" *FALLTHROUGH*
2022/01 - Pokémon Blue Version "A Scent of Lavender"
2022/01 - Spider-Man and Venom: Maximum Carnage "Heated Battle"
2022/01 - Spider-Man and Venom: Maximum Carnage "Story Interlude"
2022/01 - Unreal "Sunrise on Na Pali"
2022/02 - Final Fantasy 5 & 10 "Sovitus"
2022/02 - Final Fantasy 8 "Where Is My Fault?" *PROJECT*
2022/02 - Kenshi "When the Phoenix Doesn't Revive"
2022/02 - Mega Man 3 "My Sweet Gemini"
2022/02 - Minecraft "Pigmosh"
2021/02 - Okami "Into the Ocean We Walk Peering Way Past the Snake"
2022/02 - Phantasy Star 4 "The End of the Chillennium"
2022/02 - Prince of Persia "119 Minutes Left"
2022/02 - Super Mario 64 "The Slow Pull of the Space Docks"
2022/03 - Radical Dreamers "Treasure Beyond Dreams"
2022/05 - Hollow Knight "Mystic Mycology"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Liontamer changed the title to Currently in the Judging Process (updated May 31, 2022)
  • Liontamer changed the title to Currently in the Judging Process (updated March 8, 2022)
  • Rexy unlocked and locked this topic
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...