ReMix: Final Fantasy IX 'Qu's Marsh (Swamp Rat)'
- Game: Final Fantasy IX (Square, 2000, PS1)
- ReMixer(s): Steve Pordon
- Composer(s): Nobuo Uematsu
- Song(s): 'Marsh of the Qu Tribe'
- Posted: 2002-01-24, evaluated by djpretzel
Mainly due to a stripped-down intro that exposes the choir patch used a bit much, the first bit of this submission from Mr. Pordon, which he actually sent in quite awhile ago, didn't strike me quite right. The timpani patch used is unique though - appears to have a bit of a chorus/flange on it. When the main melody comes in at 0'42", things click more into place and it's very much an 'ah, so THAT'S where he's going with this' moment. The lil-drummer-boy snare pattern that comes in is tight, and stereo separation is such that you can track each element individually in the mix. I like the arrangement, but do have a beef with some of the patches used (in particular the choir), and would have liked to have heard some reverb or some DSP to give it a bit more ambience. Nevertheless, it is an hypnotic number, and the main melody - mixed loudest - sounds quite good.
Wow that piano sticks out though. The drums also stick out too. Arrangement-wise, I don't also see terribly much differing from the original. Just not a memorable piece, sorry Steve.
- Bahamut on September 14, 2009
- Evil_Cronos on January 5, 2009
- DragonAvenger on September 30, 2008
I've always loved Qu's Marsh and this arrangement is pretty decent, too bad with the GM.
- Another Soundscape on December 6, 2007
Sorry but the sound quality of this really prevents me from getting into this. There are some good ideas presented, but it just sounds cheap. The piano transition could have been a little less abrupt as well.
With better samples and some polish this could be an awesome mix.
- OA on February 22, 2007
FinalGamer wrote: This is a strange idea on the Qu's Marsh, making it darker and fugue-like.
Would suit perfectly if the Qu´s whipped up a cooking ritual, it may be a little dark, that piano helped much in that subject, the guitar likewise, got a good sound out of that one. And then the choir in the beginning, I always thought someone did that in the beginning, but that might as well be marimbas or bells or drums of some sort.
It repeats, I´ve noticed that, I thought the track had ended and gone on repeat, but when I checked it was just in the middle.
BUT, good song, Steve bringed out the Qu´s in an other perspective.
- Bummerdude on November 2, 2005
- FinalGamer on February 17, 2005
- Uberwulf X on June 30, 2003
I dont like the mood this piece has...it seems more kinda dark and dismal and hopeless, which isn't what the original had, though I dont supose this really matters on here so...
The piano sample irritates me..I dont know why, but it just sounds 'off'.
The snare sample is kinda dry and MIDI-like (though the Timpani sample is pretty sharp)
I dont like the choirs used either...they seem a little off-key and I dont like the abrupt start-stop thing they've got going on.
I'd have liked see more of the guitar, personally. I dont like the way it only played a few notes repeatedly during certain parts then was ignored (perhaps swapping the piano and guitar over could have worked)
Overall...Im divided.
Its not terrible...but then again its not fantastic either.
- Eccles on June 24, 2003
- djcubez on January 11, 2003
Well, sorry to say it but this mix really doesn't do it for me. Three are some cool parts that I can't help but enjoy, but the GM-ish sound quality and the needless repetition really drag it down. Not that bad, but not that great either.
- orkybash on May 22, 2002
Content Policy
(Submission
Agreement and Terms of Use)
Page generated Sat, 21 Nov 2009 21:16:27 -0500 in 0.0392 seconds
All compositions, arrangements, images, and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Original content is
copyright OverClocked ReMix, LLC. For information on RSS and JavaScript news feeds, linking to us, etc. please refer to resources for webmasters. Please refer to the Info section of
the site and the FAQ available there for information about the site's
history, features, and policies. Contact David W. Lloyd (djpretzel), webmaster, with
feedback or questions not answered there.
Discussion: Latest 11 comments/reviews; view the