Well... I don't know if it is an upgrade or a remix. Somehow, I don't know how I must label it.
But the point is that the game Sonic 2 is very important for me too because that game was a big part of my childhood like other Sonic games I played years ago and games that I still play in the present.
Still, I want to highlight the fact that can't make me finish this song: the big differences between comments.
1/3 of the people thinks that my version is awesome.
Other 1/3 of the people thinks it's regular.
And the rest of the people thinks that my version stinks.
I still don't know what I must to do with this big mismatch of opinions. Looks like my version tastes good for Rozovian but it doesn't looks good for Spakku. And that happened to me before with lots of people apart of Rozovian and Spakku.
What can I say in my defense? Maybe the fact that I'm doing this with love, patience and coherence. I don't want to use real instruments if it's not necesary. I just want to keep the original notes and tone, pointing to the feel of the original song with the new sound capabilities that a today's computer can bring us.
If I'm not wrong and my eyes and ears works fine, Emerald Hill is the first stage of the game and, like other Sonic games, use the same "first stage" cliché with (it will make me sound like a fag ) happy, shiny and colorful graphics... so, with that image in mind, I want to get a song that follow the same pattern.
I'm always trying that the synthesizers don't ruin the song, playing clean sound without satturation, with bells, pads and lots of other things that everyone can hear in my version. I think I can't get the same feel, for example, with real instruments. What can I put as lead instrument? A guitar? An organ? Maybe some of those could go fine but the song would not be the same.
Somebody could tell me wich lead instrument wanted to represent Sega with the original lead in the original song? I don't know, but I think that the one who I've chosen don't sounds so bad.
If somebody want to, go and visit Sonic Retro's forum and listen to other versions of Emerald Hill if you want. That will give you a clue of what we are looking for.
Still, I understand that everyone have his own opinion about music... and this is just my opinion.
Also, I still want to hear new hints to improve my version, if it deserves to be improved.
See you around!