Jump to content

Marscaleb

Members
  • Posts

    29
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Marscaleb

  1. This is SO CLOSE to being a good remix, even a great one!  But it is stopped dead in its tracks by some glaring flaws.

    What's with the engineering on this one?  It's like the artist's six year old nephew came in and starting twisting the volume knob on the tracks just to be funny.  We have these strong melodies starting and then suddenly dropping off into quiet solitude.  And elsewhere in the song it does the opposite.

  2. I really like the - I guess I would call it the "arrangement."
    But I don't like the instruments.
    It's a great tune, and I love the way it explores the melodies and moves through various "feels" behind those melodies.  But about half of these chiptune sounds just come out really poorly and are grating to my ears.
    I'd love to hear this as a different version that replaces the instruments.

  3. This is an atrocity.  The original is such a beautiful song, and it has an outstanding vocal.  But this remix runs that voice through a horrendous chopping filter.

    Look, there are ways to add a "glitching" effect that sound really cool, fun, and interesting.  But you can't just run some glitching filter on it and call it a day.  And the more "glitching" one adds, the more careful one must be with it.  But this is half the song made to sound like something is wrong with your internet connection, completely destroying a beautiful original piece.

  4. This barely sounds different than a recording someone made of a midi of the original song.

    It sounds so close to the original that I would rather just listen to the original.
    It was a fine remix back in the day, but it just doesn't hold up to modern standards.  This could be a really sweet remix if they revised it with a better sound font; up the sound quality a bit...

×
×
  • Create New...