djpretzel Posted January 25, 2004 Posted January 25, 2004 Title of remix: Super Mario RPG - Smithy's Orchestra (OCRemix) Remixer name: Blak_Omen Website: http://www.soundclick.com/blakomen Email: darketernal_13@hotmail.com Here is my orchestral take on Battle With Smithy: Part one from SMRPG. I hope you enjoy. A score is available...just to let y'all know. =P ___BLAK OMEN___
Protricity Posted January 26, 2004 Posted January 26, 2004 ftp://aripc.dhcp.asu.edu/Upload/2-18 fight against smithy.spc This is pretty cool. Lots of potential here. Awe damn, its over already... 2 minutes. I really like this. Aside from the string and flute bends, there ain't much wrong with it... except the length. 2 Minutes simply doesnt cut it for orchistral. Go for twice the length and resubmit. NO
Vig Posted January 27, 2004 Posted January 27, 2004 it is cool, indeed, but it is also 2:20. while in and of itself that number doesnt mean too much regarding my vote, this mix fails to build, elaborate, expand, change, and descend. this isnt the radio; let's try for a version for those of us with attention spans. NO
GrayLightning Posted January 27, 2004 Posted January 27, 2004 This is fantastic. String bends however aren't. I completely agree with vig and prot on this one. This is a bit too short as the ideas aren't completely realized here. Great job so far, but please work on this one more, as it feels incomplete right now. I think this would get a fast-track status if you decided to resubmit. a sad NO, for now
Malcos Posted January 27, 2004 Posted January 27, 2004 This sounds great, but I agree with what Vigilante said about it being like a radio mix, but shorter! This is something that could be really absorbing if it were longer. There are 3 types of NO's 1. No, do something else. 2. No, fix this up. 3. No we want more. This is the 3rd type. More! NO
Recommended Posts