OCR00658 - *YES* EarthBound 'Rings of Saturn Valley'

[djpretzel]

Salutations

Here is a remix of song from a SNES game Earthbound. The song is from

Saturn Valley, and is thus titled.

I'm going by the name "Jupter Crayons"...

Hope to hear from you soon

James Clark

[Saunders]

This is over the 6mb limit eh?. Of course it's also 320kbps. If the bitrate is lowered I'd say that it could be posted.. only problem is that I don't really like it myself. I'm gonna have to choose a No on this one, it just didn't grab me the way some of the other stuff here has...

(Edit) Wait, I've changed my mind. I didn't vote right away, and I left this song on loop. It kinda grew on me after the 3rd time through. I like the beat that hits at :22, there's something about it that's just making me happy now. I don't know why.

So anyways, ignore the comment above about "No" cus it's now a Yes. (Although we have to do something about the bitrate.)

[djpretzel]

I'm gonna make the 6mb limit a Lot more visible, and after I do so, anything that comes in that's over it we can simply ignore outright. Should save us time. For now, let's assume we can re-encode this mix and have everyone judge it, though for Rob it sounds like it didn't make a difference

[Saunders]

*snickers*

Wow, I should have edited just a moment sooner I suppose shouldn't have I?

[orkybash]

Woah... wacked out intro!!!

Wacked out mix, for that matter!

This is truly minamalism done well. It's too out there for me not to vote yes. In fact, I think the only thing I can really criticise is the fade-out ending.

But overall, a yes from me, and a thank you for the acid trip without acid. (:

[Joe Redifer]

This is pretty messed up. But I think it has it's place, though not in my playlist. I think this should come with a warning about being bizzarre! It gets a "yes" from me, not because I like it, but because I think that someone might dig it.

[Disco Dan]

well it IS pretty minimalistic, but not really in the Philip Glass sense, but anyway, strange is not a reason to NOT have a song up here. I personally find great joy and satisfaction in Daknit's "Little Kids Can't Fly" despite its dissonant pangs. Anyway, yeah, this guy holds the attention with varied percussion where the melody would normally be the only thing of interest. Enough changes to keep it interesting the whole way through.

DC