Well, honestly, I'm glad you said something, because I was thinking about it.
I like De Agua better. Here's my take on this - the recording's pretty bad and the playing is ehhhh. If we post it, we are essentially saying "if you're able to get a high school band to play videogame music, we'll post it" - the arrangement is basically taking the original and assigning parts to cover elements of it, then recording the result.
Granted, not everyone can do that, nor does everyone have a band at their disposal. If we posted it, we might need to say "just this once - from here on out, it'd have to be ten times better" - or we can not post it at all. Can anyone help me out? I hate to make vetoing a regular thing.
EDIT: I turned my edit into a reply, see below -prot