Protricity
-
Posts
1,309 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Articles
Profiles
Forums
Events
Posts posted by Protricity
-
-
This remix is pretty creative. Does things I wouldn't have ever thought to do.
The playing is well enough, and though some parts sound a bit fake (2:05), the piece is still within the bounds of passability (if thats a real word).
Very cool. Please make it twice as long next time.
YES
-
Yea, its just repeating and doing nothing. Its also not even similar to the original.
This remix simply doesnt... apply.
NO
-
Bassline, drums, lead, hits, strings, all the same exactly with different patches.
NO OVERRIDE
-
If anyone has the file, please link to it as I am not going to make an account.
If not, this can sit here. No priority to mixes that require excessive work to aquire.
-
Note for note with the original. Don't do that.
NO
Wow, that was quick.
The Surgeon General's Warning on Midi RippingThe Surgeon General of the Public Health Service has issued the following warning on Midi Ripping:
Midi Ripping is a major public health problem in the United States. In the past 20 years, its use has increased 30-fold; it is estimated that more than a quarter of the American population rip off midis. The age at which persons first start to import midis into FL has decreased gradually to the junior high school years. Until recently, nearly 11% of high school seniors were culprits, and although that figure has declined to 7%, its daily use still exceeds that of drumloop abuse and pirating gigasamples. In a recent study, 32% of those surveyed had ripped midis from popular game tunes during the previous 30 days, while only 25% had tried to sequence the notes themselves.
Among the known or suspected chronic effects of Midi-Ripping are:
-
short-term memory impairment and slowness of learning.
decreased sperm count and sperm motility.
interference with ovulation and pre-natal development.
impaired immune response.
possible adverse effects on heart function.
by-products of Midi-Ripping remaining in heart and soul for several weeks, with unknown consequences. The storage of these by-products increases the possiblilties for chronic, as well as residual, effects on performance, even after the acute reaction to the drug has worn off. Of special concern are the long-term developmental effects in
children and adolescents, who are particularly vulnerable to the method's behavioral and psychological effects. The "amotivational syndrome," characterized by a pattern of energy loss, diminished school performance, harmed parental relationships, and other behavorial disruptions, has been associated with prolonged Midi-Ripping by young persons. Although more research is required, recent national surveys report that 40% of heavy rippers experience some or all of those symptoms.
The Public Health Service concludes that Midi-Ripping has a broad range of psychological and biological effects, many of which are dangerous and harmful to health, and it supports the major conclusion of the National Academy of Sciences' Institute of Medicine.
Disclaimer All MMWR HTML documents published before January 1993 electronic conversions from ASCII text into HTML. This conversion may have resulted in character translation or format errors in the HTML version. Users should not rely on this HTML document, but are referred to the original MMWR paper copy for the official text, figures, and tables. An original paper copy of this issue can be obtained from the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office (GPO), Washington, DC 20402-9371; telephone: (202) 512-1800. Contact GPO for current prices.
**Questions or messages regarding errors in formatting should be addressed to mmwrq@cdc.gov.
-
-
In reason it's in edit - preferences - audio.
and in cubase?
Shit, wrong thread..
-
Since I researched it, I might as well review it.
Interesting way to turn 4/4 into 3/4. At first glance, sounded like another spc rip that bypassed the panel due to elements of ludicrous nostalgia and racial affinity, but such is not the case. This is quite an improvement over the original, with plenty of the good ole remix values: originality, improvisation, rearrangement, and sound quality.
Should have been longer.
Cool.
-
This song is the most powerful song I've ever heard. One of my favorites on this site as is Mazedude. All his shit is an inspiration.
Just great.
-
There are some off notes going on here.
One at 1:22 and again at 2:49.
This song pretty much stays on the same key the whole time. That coupled with the off notes forces me to go
NO
This song is dying for some variation. Its simply far too repetitive and simple.
-
wow...
excellent.
Everything I look for in a remix. Its all there.
The judges tend to have higher standards for piano mixes since our piano-arrangement population at OCR is so damned good. This song does not wane in the presence of the others. Its well done.
Good job.
YES
-
Ending kinda annoyed me, but this is indeed a solid rearrangement. Good mastering, Good everything.
Very enjoyable.
Could have used better drumwork. Like I said, ending is weak.
YES
-
Aside from the drumloops (original or not) this song is exactly the same as the original.
Interesting ideas, but after all this is a rearrangement/remix site. Not a original+drumloop site (or so we're trying to make it)
NO
-
This song is quite short and very similar (if not the same) to the original. It has a simple beat over it, but no variation, no real rearrangement, no improvements over the original.
Furthermore, its quite short and has no real ending.
Work on length, variation, and a real ending.
NO
-
Hehe, nice garage activity beat there. Like everything about the percussion.
Love the arrangement as well. Changes up quite a bit. Variation on everything. Skills shining through here
Nothing to say bad about this one, so
YES
-
Hehe, listened to this one a few times over. Very much like the style. Good arrangement skill.
And then....
It takes what it has and repeats some 50 more times.
It can easily make one go insane without any procautions.
I could imagine this being used in quite an effective form of torture - tie someone down to a bed and repeat this in their ears for 3-4 hours. They'll tell you everything you want to know.
Seriously though. Go for more arrangement and less repeating. A key change or something. Please
NO
-
Very Well done. Very cool. Got me laughing. I much enjoyed it.
TOO SHORT.
I'm sorry, but 1:06 doesn't much cut it as a real song. Go for more length and please resubmit. I liked it.
NO
-
Hmm. There is very little arrangement going on here. Simply original over drumloops.
You'll have to do more than that to get on this site. Sorry.
NO
-
Repetitive and similar to the original. However there is a good deal of originality. I'm sorta torn here.
Until I can think of a good reason not to, this gets a
YES
-
Hmm... that lead is really ugly. Song has movement though. Repeating a lot though.
Please go for more change up. It really doesn't NEED to repeat 4 times to be called a song.
You might wanna go for a different lead as well. The chosen is .. quite.. ugly. Kinda ruins the song.
NO
-
at 1:15 and up, its pretty much an nfs rip. Go for more than 'nes with drumloop'.
NO
-
Yea, I know its better than Rob Saunder's version.
Nevertheless, its rather identical with the original.
Need more of a 'remix' and less of a 'genre change'.
There are some volume mastering issues. Around 1:20 and up, the lead is way loud and everything else is flooded out.
Work on the mastering and the arrangement quality. Also, go for a better ending. The ending is quite... bad.
NO
-
Hmm... intro is exact with the original. Not a good sign.
At :30 still note for note...
Chords same, guitar, flutes, piano.......... exact exact.
SPC rip. Not cool.
NO OVERRIDE
-
I have no issue with the use of vocals here. Its quite creatively done. Changeups are real nice. Lots of cool drumwork and arrangement. Lots of variation.
Issue I have is that most of the song is off key; Expecially the vocals in relation to the rest. Its hard to avoid when using vocals in this nature, I know. Still its a pretty big issue.
Please fix the key issues and resubmit.
NO
EDIT:
Changing my vote to a YES after careful reconsideration. It is apparent to me now (though the key issues are still very relevant) that there is really no way to pull off this kind of song with those vocals and not have any flaws. The chorus is singing in exact chords. To prevent key issues, the chords must always be matched about the vocals. This prevents Treth from doing much. He couldn't have done any of the stuff in this song for sure were he trying to keep the key.
To deny the talent and creativity of this mix based on sheer lack of ability is quite ridiculous, and not really fair.
-
This is pretty cool. Lots of originality. Creative mastering. Good synth programmings.
Singing could be better. Lyrics could actually rhyme. Song could use more bass.
Still, these are minor issues with the song, and over all there is a great deal of movement and change ups.
Cool
YES
*NO* Chrono Trigger 'Sealed'
in Judges Decisions
Posted
Ah, new chords!1
Its interesting, yes, but as Vig put it, rather ameture. Go for a louder lead, less of an attack on the synth chords, more variation on drums and arrangement. The wind/rain sfx are overused.
Interesting, but
NO