Antonio Pizza Posted January 4, 2003 Posted January 4, 2003 Antonio: I have a submission that's hit the magical two month mark, and I was hoping you could help me. The song is entitled "Last Gasp", and it's a piano remake of the Wily stages of Mega Man 6. Here's the link: Thanks, Nemo Patrick Dubuque gordon@u.washington.edu *NOTE* It's been about 3 months now...sorry Nemo . Anyways, the song in question is track 12 on the .nsf.
Antonio Pizza Posted January 5, 2003 Author Posted January 5, 2003 Well since it's a piano piece (which used to be the favored here a while back), it's probably going to get an auto "no" from a couple of the judges and an auto "yes" from a couple others. Hmmm...damn, I'm torn. It is a nice piano piece but it's pretty much follows the original without much variation. AAAGGGGGHHHHHERRRGGGHH!!! well... screw it. gotta follow through (i'm kickin' myself SO hard for this) No. Daniel's past statements are correct. We can't allow pieces on soley because they're piano pieces. Pretzel said the new year must usher in a raised bar in OCR standards... but he also said to stick to your gut (more or less in them words). I want to share this with SOOOOOO many other people. F*** it. S*** happens. No. It's just the piano and reverb done verbatim.
Protricity Posted January 5, 2003 Posted January 5, 2003 NO nice, but very simple. Piano pieces must go beyond such simplicity. This song generally just follows the melody of that cool original. Also there are sound/velocity problems.
DarkCecil13 Posted January 5, 2003 Posted January 5, 2003 This does indeed follow the melody of the original super directly. Much too simplistic. I also believe there's too much reverb for my ears to handle. NO
Saunders Posted January 6, 2003 Posted January 6, 2003 - On a quick listen, it's not unpleasant, actually quite nice. - Not much variation from the original. Too simple. Vote: No
Disco Dan Posted January 6, 2003 Posted January 6, 2003 You make me proud, boys, you make me proud! *wipes a tear from his eye* DC P.S. PIANO PLAYERS: GET YOUR FOOT OFF OF THAT PEDAL!
Recommended Posts