Judges Decisions

6,660 topics in this forum

1. Currently in the Judging Process (updated May 31, 2022)

   By Liontamer, April 21, 2005
   • 1 reply
   • 375.5k views
   • 
   • DragonAvenger
   • August 4, 2011

2. Why Links to Rejections Are Removed

   By djpretzel, March 11, 2003
   • 18 replies
   • 41k views
   • 
   • Digital Coma
   • August 8, 2004

3. *NO* Golden Sun "Circles in the Sand"

   By Chimpazilla, May 22
   • 3 replies
   • 68 views
   • 
   • prophetik music
   • June 23

4. *NO* Mega Man Zero 4 "Frente en Alto"

   By Emunator, May 22
   • 3 replies
   • 64 views
   • 
   • prophetik music
   • June 24

5. *NO* Dragon Warrior 2 "Epic Footsteps" *RESUB*

   By Emunator, May 22
   • 3 replies
   • 88 views
   • 
   • Chimpazilla
   • June 12

6. *NO* Unreal "Sunrise on Na Pali"

   By Emunator, May 22
   • 3 replies
   • 64 views
   • 
   • prophetik music
   • June 24

7. *NO* Golden Axe "A Golden Axe Journey" *FALLTHROUGH*

   By Emunator, May 15
   • 3 replies
   • 103 views
   • 
   • DarkSim
   • June 11

8. *NO* Mario Kart 64 "Toad's Nightride"

   By Emunator, May 9
   • 3 replies
   • 151 views
   • 
   • Liontamer
   • May 11

9. *NO* Ape Escape & Bomberman Hero "Re:Dial (But When the Phone Rings, Let the Monkey Answer)"

   By Emunator, May 7
   • 4 replies
   • 200 views
   • 
   • Liontamer
   • May 31

10. *NO* Super Mario Sunshine "Love on Noki Beach"

    By Emunator, April 30
    • 3 replies
    • 100 views
    • 
    • MindWanderer
    • May 31

11. *NO* Super Mario Bros. 2 "Subcon on Mushrooms"

    By Emunator, April 30
    • 3 replies
    • 117 views
    • 
    • Liontamer
    • May 31

12. OCR04346 - *YES* Street Fighter 2 "Chun-Li: Lady Dragon"

    By Emunator, April 30
    • 4 replies
    • 100 views
    • 
    • MindWanderer
    • May 10

13. *NO* Dark Souls 2 "Majules"

    By Emunator, April 30
    • 3 replies
    • 96 views
    • 
    • prophetik music
    • June 24

14. *NO* Punch-Out!! "The Good, the Bad, and the Punched in the Face"

    By Emunator, April 23
    • 3 replies
    • 115 views
    • 
    • MindWanderer
    • May 11

15. *NO* Mega Man 3 "The Spark Is Gone"

    By Emunator, April 23
    • 3 replies
    • 92 views
    • 
    • Liontamer
    • May 29

16. *NO* Super Castlevania 4 "Whip of Justice"

    By Emunator, April 23
    • 3 replies
    • 142 views
    • 
    • DarkSim
    • May 10

17. *NO* Splatoon 2 "Exodus (The Endless Harvest)"

    By Emunator, April 23
    • 3 replies
    • 156 views
    • 
    • Chimpazilla
    • May 4

18. *NO* Dissidia: Final Fantasy "Reditus Solis"

    By Emunator, April 23
    • 3 replies
    • 62 views
    • 
    • prophetik music
    • June 23

19. OCR04326 - *YES* Donkey Kong Country 2 & Donkey Kong 64 "Bavarian Kackle" *RESUB*

    By Emunator, March 27
    • 4 replies
    • 162 views
    • 
    • DarkSim
    • March 30

20. *NO* Return of Ishtar "Ishtar's Embrace"

    By Emunator, December 21, 2021
    • 3 replies
    • 157 views
    • 
    • MindWanderer
    • April 1

21. *NO* Persona 4 "I Like (Your Affection)"

    By Emunator, December 21, 2021
    • 3 replies
    • 128 views
    • 
    • Chimpazilla
    • June 12

22. OCR04324 - *YES* Super Metroid & Metroid "Concealed Caverns"

    By Emunator, December 20, 2021
    • 4 replies
    • 198 views
    • 
    • Emunator
    • March 26

23. *NO* Castlevania: The Adventure "Holy Battle"

    By Emunator, December 20, 2021
    • 3 replies
    • 143 views
    • 
    • prophetik music
    • March 22

24. *NO* F-Zero "When Your Mom Mistakes Captain Falcon for Captain America Again"

    By Emunator, December 19, 2021
    • 5 replies
    • 133 views
    • 
    • DarkSim
    • April 21

25. OCR04326 - *YES* Final Fantasy Adventure "Palace of Memory"

    By Emunator, December 19, 2021
    • 4 replies
    • 132 views
    • 
    • Liontamer
    • March 26