djpretzel Posted April 29, 2003 Posted April 29, 2003 LINK REMOVED BECAUSE WE ARE BAD JUDGES AND WE HATE STUFF AND ARE ANGSTY, ETC! remix i did from chrono trigger.. email me back when you put it up edit by 68030 for link stuff
Protricity Posted April 29, 2003 Posted April 29, 2003 Hmm, note for note intro. Lets see where it goes. 0:30 Note for note still. 0:40 Note for note still. 0:50 Note for note still. 1:00 Note for note still. 1:10 Note for note still. 1:20 Note for note still. 1:30 Note for note still. 1:40 Note for note still. ok, thats all I need to hear. NO no spc rips please.
m68030 Posted May 5, 2003 Posted May 5, 2003 past the fact that this is too close to the original I offer the following: the bass at 1:20 sounds slightly dissonant.. the brass section at 1:40 (french horn?) sounds quite nice. the lead instrument is a little too dry. More dynamic range would be nice. bass back in at 2:10ish sounds dissonant again. Too characteristic? The stabby lines around 2:30 - 3:00 are a little boring without much to back them up. The pingpong echo is kinda neat, but could be more defined. just sounds flat. The lead reintroduced in the next section, again, a little lifeless. The violin in the background has an odd sample loop point, might try replacing that with another soundfont, assuming that's what you're using. However, being that this is note for note the spc, with nicer instruments, I have to vote NO Develop the themes or maybe work a medley together, and then you'll have something more fitting of our guidelines.
analoq Posted May 7, 2003 Posted May 7, 2003 after reviewing the original, i would have to suggest submitting this to vgmusic.com instead. this site is for arrangements. no
Disco Dan Posted May 8, 2003 Posted May 8, 2003 well the bass at 1:20 is just really muddy because it's like chords at a really deep register. Just comes across really cloudy. Anyway, most of this has already been said, so I won't rehash. But it does seem more like an instrumental update than an arrangement or interpretation. Gonna have to go with the rest of the guys with: NO D
Recommended Posts