*NO* Final Fantasy 10 'Sin Insurance'

[DragonAvenger]

Sorce - Final Fantasy X, Besaid Island

Be gentle with me, It's my first remix XD

-------------------------------------------

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j2UjfueRo7g

My Besaid bias made me have to panel this. It's clever!

[Fishy]

I enjoyed the telephone line and the name idea. Nice FFX joeks too.

The arrangement however is just too undeveloped. There's not a great deal added, it just feels like a slower more spacey/reverberant soundscape. I couldn't really hear much of a structure and the ending was a abrupt. The sounds used feel pretty MIDI/basic, especially the lead guitar sound.

It was fun, but the arrangement is too conservative for OCR.

NO

[DragonAvenger]

Not much to add to Fishy's vote. The whole 'Insurance wait music' was a fun idea, but the arrangement just isn't up to our standards. Along with that the sounds are not the greatest, which is a secondary issue to the arrangement, but still important.

Sorry, but this is a NO

[OceansAndrew]

The concept of this was amazing, I loved the little vocal clips, and the menu of items was hilarious. Excellent creativity and idea. Unfortunately, the remix itself wasn't up to the same standards. There were some good counterpoint ideas, but the melody and structure stayed pretty static. It's a tough situation, because hold music is inherently bland and cheesy, but I think the melody could be altered a little, and things could be expanded a bit. The samples are ok, but not awesome, and some additional panning and processing could help the sound as well.

I really love the concept, but it needs to be a bit more dynamic musically.

No, please resubmit