Antonio Pizza Posted November 27, 2002 Posted November 27, 2002 Well, you made the post in the "Judges Decisions" forum over at OC that if it had been a month or 2, that an e-mail of some sort should be sent along to a judge. So here is my e-mail to you These 2 submissions probably got passed over due to VGMix going offline and being unable for download since that was the only link I had at the time. My apologies for that, not that I had any control over it. Anyway, I would greatly appreciate it if you could slide these in sometime soon since they are both a month old. Name/Handle: Hermit E-Mail: transparentenigma@hotmail.com Submitted September 24, 2002. Reflections of Hyrule: EDIT: This is one of two.
Protricity Posted November 28, 2002 Posted November 28, 2002 So, is this LOTR sound track or Zelda? It sounds nice, but its too simple, too easy going, and ultimately too uninteresting. I would like to see more happen with remixes that have been done 100 times. NO
DarkCecil13 Posted November 28, 2002 Posted November 28, 2002 Nothing happens. This mix is ultimately boring. Several of the samples (the winds) "stand out". Not a good thing More could be happening here. NO
orkybash Posted November 28, 2002 Posted November 28, 2002 This is beautiful, but ultimately pretty simplistic. It's a tough call, but overall I've gotta say NO just because it doesn't realy expand on a theme that's been expanded on a lot before. Develop the ideas a little more so there's more going on, and make sure you're not just making us listen to something we've already heard.
Saunders Posted November 30, 2002 Posted November 30, 2002 Slow. Sweet. Simple. New takes on the popular themes are definitely encouraged though, and I don't see this mix taking us into territory not already covered by other mixes. Vote: No
Recommended Posts