Antonio Pizza Posted November 27, 2002 Posted November 27, 2002 You say to mail you if it's been a month or two since a mix was submitted, so here I am. Red Nostalgia v. 2 was submitted by myself in September or early October, as I recall, maybe earlier, and I have seen no sign of it. The address it can be DL'd from is . I do not ask that you evaluate it immediately, just making sure it's somewhere on the queue (I received a confirmation mail when I submitted it first). I'd also understand if there is some delay in evaluating it due to the finnicky nature of the geocities page (much over 4 meg, which is about the size of RN, per hour and I exceed allotted bandwidth and the site drops for a while). If it's on the queue, fine, I trust you'll get to it in due time (although an e-mail stating as much would not be unwelcome), otherwise getting to it within a month or so would be nice. And if my track record is against me here, I assure you this one isn't at all as repetitive as Hair's Breadth. Short, perhaps, but not repetitive. - seanstar
Protricity Posted November 28, 2002 Posted November 28, 2002 Cant get the file. Anyone wanna help out? Review pending Pros: Nice reexpression of these classic themes. Cons: It sounds like 2 different songs stuck together The composition sounds weak and hollow. Im really not sure about this mix. Although I dont much care for it, I am also very tired. I'll let it sit in my mind for a while, listen to it a few more times, etc. Review later Review NOW The composition really lacks, Im gonna have to go with a NO
Antonio Pizza Posted November 29, 2002 Author Posted November 29, 2002 I'm not feelin' this one. I don't care for the samples. I do like the tempo changes and segues, but I'd find some better samples. They just don't fit well with me. No.
Malcos Posted November 29, 2002 Posted November 29, 2002 The arrangement is ok, but the tempo changes are not to my taste at all. There is a lot of variety in the mix, but the sounds are so General Midi soundset, and the percussion could be a lot more defined. NO
Saunders Posted November 30, 2002 Posted November 30, 2002 I have .mid's that sound better than this (sample wise). The arrangement is.. well it's not horrible I think. Try sprucing this up with some tasty soundfonts or samples, anything if you can get it sounding less like a .mid file. I like Zero's theme and to hear it not be done justice breaks my heart. Vote: No
Recommended Posts