Protricity
-
Posts
1,309 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Articles
Profiles
Forums
Events
Posts posted by Protricity
-
-
Knowing this (and every other dkc) song by heart, I can conclude that this is another note-for note rendition. Sure there are a few additions (and subtractions) but basically its the original with new instruments.
The original sounds better.
NO
Oh, and there are out of tune instruments (vocals)
-
Very repetitive, lead instrument could be better. I would watch the release (that is the thing that controls how quickly a note fades once it is ended (released)).
I would recommend the author work on expantion of a melody rather than just adding more and more background distortion
NO
-
Lets learn how to do drums.
While we're at it, lets learn to not rip the spc and make songs that are note for note the same as the original.
Probably askin too much here...
NO
-
I would give this a NO on the bitrate alone.
But other than that, the beat sounds off. I think it could use some quantization.
Furthermore, this is almost exactly the same as the original.
Lastly, the unchanging frequency cut lead and repetitive beat alone would force me to say NO
-
Its repetitive, but sounds very nice
Something that should definately be on oc
I really like it
NO
why? hehhe
trailing silence
have it fixed, and I'll put a yes
-
NO
nice, but very simple. Piano pieces must go beyond such simplicity. This song generally just follows the melody of that cool original.
Also there are sound/velocity problems.
-
Sorry man, more is required than a simple disco beat with random melodies over it. I like the original songs too, that was kinda disappointing. This might have even been good if the beat was changed up a bit more and that drumloop wasnt ever present. Also, the minimalisticness is kinda eck.
Very repetitve
Good sound though.
NO
-
I am so certain that we reviewed this before.
Perhaps not, but I think we did
In any rate, I made my decision on this song long ago and it hasnt changed with this hearing. I dont like the melody at all. There are parts where the melody just dont fit. I dont like how it was done. I dont like the effects.
I like the concept. It could have been more interesting if it was done better, etc
so NO
-
Very interesting interpretation of very good songs.
That beat is way quiet
Its better now.. but beat should be louder
ack, hella reverb
gettin repetitive...
That reverb is a little too much at time
Hmm, somehow I remember this being better.
Im kinda borderline. Im gonna go with NO cause Its just too repetitive and doesnt do much with the great song. And the over use of reverb and fx kills me
-Pro
-
The first was around October 29 and the second was around November 13.
All three of the files I have submitted in the last 3 months can be found at
Thanks again!
-waxingeloquent
So uh, I guess we'll start with his first submission. We only allow one submission at a time anyway.
So, THIS is the song
submitted 3 months ago. I know this cause I remember him telling me he submitted it back then.
-Pro
-
WOW!!!!!!!!!!
This is by far the most impressive song I've heard for a long time.
I am seriously impressed here. VERY good concepts here.
VERY NICE
No Cons, more Pros than I can think of
YES
-Pro
EDIT: Yes, this could have been much longer. Pleast work on the duration in the near future. GJ
-
There ye go
he says this version is perfect, I dont have the time to check, but he said there are no glitches this time
-Pro
EDIT: Aprentis tells me theres a glitch at 0:16 now. I hear it, but its rather minute.
He is gonna try again tomarrow. Lets wait for a better version.
EDIT2: Ok, he uploaded the godforsaken file one final time and there are no godforsaken glitches. Maybe NOW I can get some GODFORSAKEN sleep around here.
-
I PMed the guy about the glitch, maybe he can fix it in time.
-
Somehow the melody reminded me of the Ending theme to Zelda 4. Hmm, oh well.
A very well put together song. Not too simple, not too boring or repetitive.
Very impressive.
YES
EDIT: Hmm, this sounds like it was ripped off a cd. Whats up with that? At least fix the audio distortions. Theres one at 2:03.
-
Stop using Mp3.com
Seriously.
Stop it.
Hey now, there's always worse . . . btw, what's your vote?
Well, It was taking so long to register with mp3.com, then the explorer froze when I submitted. Then I got pissed, gave up and went to class. Then I ... kinda... lost my internet for a week.
So I'll vote now.
OMFG. I was putting bullshit in for the mp3.com registration, and put in 1999 for my birthday. It said:
Thank you for your interest in MP3.com. Unfortunately, due to the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA), we will need to redirect you to another web site within the Vivendi Universal Family of companies. We apologize for any inconvenience this may pose.
Then It blocked my computer from accessing any of the pages!
I am seriously starting to get sick of this mp3.com shit.
Anyway, lets see if someone else happens to have the song...
Askin Cotmm...
please standby...
Alright got it
Pro(s):
LOL!!!!!!! I love what you did with that voice sample! That made me laugh pretty hard. Almost makes sense, almost.
Great Feel
Ugh(s):
This song has been done so many times. This time its really nothing new, except that a dance beat was used with tamborines instead of hats. WOW!
I dont see anything unique about this song except that it had a very nice feel to it. Too bad that feel really had nothing to do with the melodys found in zebes.
Better luck next time
NO
-
Heh, nice reviews.. now I gotta hear this...
Hehe, yes, Some guys shouldn't rap.
I cant understand half of it anyway.
NO
-
I did this in a couple hours one day when i was bored at work
-serficus winthrax
Sounds like it
Pro(s):
Nice feel, but not really.
Ugh(s):
Beat sounds far away from the guitar, like another song thats playing in the background.
Song is way too repetitive and short. It doesnt really stray from the original at all, it just goes over the melody with strange guitars and a simplistic beat.
I liked how it sounded, but the truth is, it REALLY did sound like a hurried song.
Please attempt more varaiety in the future kthx
NO
-
Pro(s):
Very cool interpretation of the original.
When I saw the title, I was quite worried that it would be another midi rip with off notes and general disarrangement of the original... ehem... uh, never mind.
Ugh(s):
The intro is nice, but should be 5 seconds long, not 30 seconds.
The beat never really developed, It just continued with those sine hits.
Song repeats D:
This is the kinda song that REALLY REALLY REALLY needs a rockin beat to make it MOVE. If it had a better beat, it would actually be much better. I never thought I would say that, oh well.
I really like the ideas presented here, but because the beat never developed (and stayed with those simple sine hits and hat taps) The whole song feels like one big intro.
Please submit with a rockin beat and I'll love you forever M@
NO
-
I dont remember this at all.
I'll check the Birdo Mini-boss theme when I get home.
Pros:
...
Cons:
I dont really like the part that starts at 0:01 and goes until, um.... 4:43. That part hits me the wrong way.
No seriously, this is too simple, repetitive. It holds no musical aspect of the originals. It feels like someone's second attempt at FL.
Skills take time to develop, remember that.
Although, I commend kyle for surpassing the 2:20 limit that seems to have possesion of all recent submissions.
NO
-
Pros
Nice arranging abilities. I actually like that bass, It sounds like synth, but it could be a tuba. I dont know. All I know is that I like how it sounds
Cons
Repetitive
Short
Ending could have been more interesting.
I would like to see this more expressive and less repetitive .. and LONGER. Very nice work, just do more, that is all.
NO
-
Pros:
I guess the sines sound good, but in an ambient-sense. I dont think it does the original justice.
Cons:
Awe hell, when did I get over 500 posts? Now I feel dirty.
HOLY SHORT!
What is with all the 2 minute songs?
Really not impressed by the minimalistic nature of the song. So much can be done with a great song like this.
Now I feel bad for rejecting 2 beej songs. I just really have problems with songs that are A. Very short and B. Very minimalistic. Also, I just really have problems. Maybe Master will kick my ass about this later, I dunno
NO
-
Pros:
Nice orchistra arrangement. I really havent heard this kind of arrangement on this site before. (Im sure another exists, but I haven't heard it)
Cons:
Ending is rather abrupt and unresolved, as Dan and Cotmm said, even though Dan is a stuck-up Cuban Fag.
I have a problem with the high note at exactly 1:54 , but oh well, thats probably how the original went.
Too damn short.
I like it, very nicely done. Lets work on those endings a bit, though. 2 minutes is ridiculously short. Its a sign of lazyness to me. ANY song can be longer than 2 minutes.
YES
-
Pros:
Good sound. Good use of instruments.
Cons:
Nothing really special. Just follows the melody with orchistra instead of saws and squares.
I wasnt too impressed by this mix because I dont feel anything was really done to it. It feels like the original with different samples. I can tell a mix isnt really my thing when I go back and listen to the original and realize I would rather hear the original.
Still, there were a few creative elements to this song and a reasonable bitrate was presented, FOR ONCE, the melody had a clear and open feel.
So, YES
-
Pros:
Nice movement
Cons:
too short
Noteoff ending
no variation on the melody or beat
It would have been nice if it had just been longer ~4+ minutes and had more varaiety.
NO
*NO* Final Fantasy 6 'Aria'
in Judges Decisions
Posted
Heh, I cant rate this properly with such a horrible rendition. Try 112 kbps minimum for mp3 stereo 44khz songs plz.
Personally, I hate the vocals. Creative, but thats no justification.
Secondly, this is very cookie cutter - the usual dance beat, however I do like how the melody was attacked.
There are off key sections towards the end.
Interesting concept, but wholely unsuccessful.
NO