Malcos

This sounds passive and flat. It's just really boring. Really boring. NO

The mixing on this needs some work. The instruments on this sound really separate, if that makes any sense. Drums sound muffled, and some synths are much too loud compared to others. Arrangement is good, but for me the mixing spoiled it completely. NO

The drums are obviously the main thing here, being the loudest element by far and they carry the whole song. DrumGeistRecordings. Yep, it's all about drums. At the very beginning of the mix, the drum work is kinda confusing, until it settles for the groove we will hear through the main mix. The drums sound great, but at the expense of everything else. The other sounds need mixing as well! The notes at times all meld and it get messy. The choice of synths, particularly the 'wowy' synth bass didn't compliment the drums IMO. Great drums, but that's it really. NO

Wow, this was really short. More, more! So short it was frustrating. The reverb was excessive, but artistic nontheless. Sounded nice. But tooooo short. NO

I can hear parts where the drums and the guitars are out of sync. I also think this needs some low frequencies. The fadeout ending really did feel out of place. Too short. NO

Oh, HELL NO.

This mix has a lack of high frequencies. It sounds ok, but needs to expand from those 2 chords, it does get annoying after a while. Vary it up. NO

For some reason this isn't letting me download from the webexplorer webspace.

Well this mix created a vibe and managed to do a medely without breaking the rhythm. Nice. YES

This sounds like it's a remix of the shiva guy you face just before Mr.X (I played this game toooo much). Whine-oh-crash! The mix sounds like it's distorting at some points. Ouchy! A lot more could have been done in the second half, something completely different. The programming is good. This mix is leaning towards a NO, for the most part because of the distortion.

This sounds very nice indeed (well he's using a Motif!) However, the eq is questionable - IMHO, the piano is too bright, and the drums need to be brightened up. The mix itself was also quite repetitive and got boring after a while. NO

I know this is short, but somehow it seemed really repetitive, and the lack of dynamics was really obvious. Where are the quiet bits that build up? Where is the emotion? NO

Wow these guitars are really powerful. Because of all the sounds it becomes almost saturated at times, but I'm assuming that was one of the aims of the piece. Good stuff. YES

Hmmm... Well it started off ok, and I expected some progression. Unfortunately, half way through this turns into the prelude theme, with very annoying 'glingy' synths. This doesn't add anything to the orginal themes, just some panned monotonous synthy stuff. Didn't do it for me. NO

Very cool, peaceful and refreshing. Nice work. Doesn't vary hugely, but the mix has enough elements to it, and it flows. This works. YES

Well I really liked the drum work on this mix, and the synth sounds were very appropriate. It could have done with something else to focus on near the end, and so I agree with m68030 on that point. Good enough for OC though I reckon. YES

Not too bad, but not only is it not different enough from the actual theme, the mix itself doesn't actually have enough variation in it to keep a high level of interest throughout. Needs more, more I tells ya! NO

Well there are a lot of effects in this mix. Lots of high frequencies make this sound like high quality stuff. The arrangement isn't all that, and could have been much more varied. However, I think this is OCR quality. YES

What we gonna do? It seems we've just ignored him? This thread here is stale, we should try and move it on out.

Wow, damn this has been sitting here for tooooooo long. This is too fruityloopy, and doesn't have much to it. Drum beat, and a couple synths. Ending is just like, bluh. NO

Too repetitive, over-use of drum loop after drum loop. The ending is just bleh. NO

It's all put together very well, but there's hardly any real remixing of music going on here. If you take away the samples, there's not much left. And where there are actual musical notes, I hear some off-key notes. NO

This really was programmed. There is no way this sounds played. It's just flat and emotionless. NO

Sounds like the original, a lot like the orginal. Nasty sounds. NO

Ok well, this is so good that it overcomes the bitrate issue. Yes this is good enough to make an exception. Yes yes yes YES