maybe pewdiepie has 12million alt accounts, and he's not really as popular as he makes it seem. one can only hope.
I would endorse Gamegrumps , but I can only mainly recommend Jon-era grumps. Danny just doesnt do it for me, although steam rolled is pretty good.
I used to watch Two Best Friends Play a lot, they are great, highly recommeneded.
SomeOrdinaryGamers is really good, he does Playthroughs of various things, and does creepypasta readings.
I also Enjoy Yuri of Wind sometimes. He does a few different things on his channel, I don't really know what i would classify it as.
Spigazusaur is good too, he does game reviews, his accent is a little hard to understand sometimes, but he's good.
ModernWarNegro is pretty funny too, does a few different things on his channel. you may or may not like it, it depends.
and how could I almost forget Cr1TiKaL? Give him a try sometime, he's probably one of my absolute favorite youtubers