can't really say since i'm still relatively new to the site in general, but I think its fine. It just seems out of order cuz theres not many people submiting there versions of the song and some people might see more love than others just for that fact. Overall, i don't think its in a situation where it needs a Dramatic change.
and u prolly shouldn't have to worry about how the MnP works cuz i now understand y its made... I won't lie though, at first I thought it was dumb that u couldn't make ur own interpretation and thought that this site was the whole reason for doing so. However as I participated in the previous MnP and listened to the other MnP tracks, I can now say that this is a good idea. Forcing people to come up with different styles/ideas for the song WHILE staying true to the original format is actually challenging.
besides, if the person really wanted to make it different/orignal then that is what the other competitions are for. Its really great to change the pace now and then.