Jump to content

Logic 9 is out


Recommended Posts

the *general* rule of thumb is that 3rd party plugins are better, because that's primarily their thang, ya know?

I'm not saying that Logic doesn't do a good job, but take Fishy's statement about Guitar Rig. Even if the sound quality/modeling is comparable, I highly doubt that Logic will beat GR's interface, not to mention the awesome Rig Kontrol option.

Again, this is not *always* the case, but it's a fairly safe rule to live by just the same.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm definitely on board for Logic 9. I've been in dire need of an upgrade, as I've been working off of Logic Express 7. It gets me through, but this will be muuuuch better. I'll update once I get ahold of it and test out all the new guitar stuff. Although I won't be able to compare it to Guitar Rig on my own, considering I don't have it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Did they happen to make the piano roll less crappy? (aka, more like FL's). That's my primary hangup considering how much time I spend in the PR. Otherwise, I'd probably just go ahead and switch to Logic for my primary DAW. I love the way Logic handles automation, not to mention the single-window interface, which is effin brilliant. I just do so hate their PR... (also, I consider FL's mixer slightly more intuitive).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you got GR3 with the controller Fishy, then no, you didn't waste money. Shit is sweet.:P

And yeah, I'm going to update probably. I like the new multitracking, and the notation looks nice, and I don't want to buy finale or sibelius. Money I could spend on turntables.:P

Soundtrack Pro 3 looks sick too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

what is you don't like about the piano roll jimmy?

first of all the color coded velocities is super helpful which fl misses out on

If I may interject here, color coded velocities have nothing on the super simple editing of velocities that FL has. Just have the mouse in the general proximity of a note velocity on the bottom of the piano roll and adjust it to taste with a single click and without changing editing tools. You can also sweep the mouse across the velocities to change groups of them at once if you want. In Logic, as far as I can tell, you must have the pointer tool out and must click on the velocity and drag it to where you want it. And I know you can sweep across groups of velocities at once but I can't get it to work half the time. Basically, this stuff equates to more work and time, and it adds up quick.

Also, my personal favorite feature of FL's piano roll, keyboard shortcuts where you don't have to manually switch back to your previous tool. Like if I want to cut a note I hold shift with the pencil tool active and it changes to the cutting tool. After I cut the note it switches back to the pencil tool automatically. Or I can hold shift+alt to cut while bypassing quantize settings.

I have been trying to make the switch to Logic but the piano roll is a huge snag. I don't know if I'll ever get used to it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

whoa! you didn't start trashing logic in a logic thread did you xD

but i do want to understand the differences so thanks for chiming in

logic has a pane at the bottom of the piano roll that pulls up velocities and you can do one clicks and grab as well as lines (line tool) - but even easier for me for small tweaks is assigning my command tool in the piano rolls as my velocity tool so i can command click and watch the velocity change right there. another thing to consider with editing is logic's transform command window which can change huge amounts of data in an automated fashion that can save lots of time.

logic has 3 tools at your fingertips at all times - with right clicking, and command clicking - you also have a zoom tool there so thats 4 - hitting esc you get all your tools right there - so it doesn't take much more time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't get the wrong idea. I'm not trying to trash Logic, I'm actually very interested in learning better ways to do things in the program. Just pointing out the differences I've seen that make an impact in my experience.

In FL you don't have to actually drag the velocity, you just click where you want it to be and it pops into place. I guess that's the biggest difference there. Hitting esc is a good time saver that I was not aware of.

Honestly if they did something like Sonar where you can customize what the mouse does down to the finest details, I would probably just switch to Logic altogether. I am a huge fan of the included plugins (Sculpture ftw) and I actually prefer many aspects of the workflow. But when I spend 90% of the time in the piano roll, it needs to be lightning fast.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

well - like i said - you can bring up that other window at the bottom and see strictly velocity info and do one click edits if holding a modifier and dragging is too much work

RU talking about the Event window?

Honestly if they did something like Sonar where you can customize what the mouse does down to the finest details, I would probably just switch to Logic altogether.

I know in Logic 7 Pro you can COMPLETELY customize the short keys, MIDI controllers, and interface. I never took the time to learn in Studio, but I'm sure the didn't pitch that function in 9.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ok - pulled the trigger on 9

haven't gotten to mess with everything (like flex) but about the amps - i'm pretty shocked with some of the tones i'm getting - i went direct and was pretty sad at first - but i mic'd a clean signal and am getting some pretty awesome tones - standard metal guitar is not really happening as well as gr3 but everything else sounds great - i can get some pretty dirty and even rough tones but i like metal guitar stuff to be tight and controlled

want to get more into flex time - been hearing about some bugs people have been finding on the net

back to the piano roll - here's a brief video showing the pane i'm talking about

http://www.ehow.com/video_4460334_piano-roll-options-logic-pro.html

another thing to consider when editing in logic is the hyper editor which often gets overlooked - you can do volume and other data in musical divisions more similar to fl - if thats what your looking for - and you program drums similiar to fl too - the only thing is logic gives you so much flexibility that you have to go in there and kinda program you want to get the desired effect - but once you take a little of time and know what you like - it's pretty easy - i did one for my addictive drum set and it's pretty killer and intuitive

here's some info on hyper

http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/apr08/articles/logictech_0408.htm

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Logic's piano roll is just plain awful compared to FL's. Here is why FL has the best piano roll:

* Left click once to create a note. The note created has the same duration as the last note you drew.

* Left click and drag on a note to move it in any direction.

* Left click and hold while creating a note to move it around in any direction.

* Right click to turn the cursor into a delete tool.

* Left click and drag the end of a note to resize.

So simple, yet every DAW gets it wrong. Creating, moving and deleting notes is what I spend 99% of my time doing in the piano roll. I should NEVER have to touch my keyboard or switch tools to do any of these things. Everything should be extremely fluid. Logic feels like molasses in comparison.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

* Left click once to create a note. The note created has the same duration as the last note you drew.

* Left click and drag on a note to move it in any direction.

* Left click and hold while creating a note to move it around in any direction.

* Right click to turn the cursor into a delete tool.

* Left click and drag the end of a note to resize.

Assign Pencil tool to left mouse click. (does everything listed above; AND you can double click on a note to delete it)

Enable right mouse click to be a tool. Assign Eraser tool. (can be assigned to anything)

Switch the "command" button on the keyboard to be the Select tool and you can select large groups of notes for editing then.

And these settings can be kept so you don't have to switch things every time.

( Logic 8 )

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah I have used both too. The pencil tool does those things you described exactly the same. Really don't know what to say to ya dude. Yeah there are other differences in the overall piano roll, but in the functionality described above they are the same. I would make a video but I am swamped with work. :sleepdepriv:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Zirc - just like shaun said - it's all there - you can't refute it

Now I have 3 tools easily at my disposal with left, right, and with my command click (you can't really say that hitting an easy modifier is that much trouble :P). I usually have my pointer tool on left and pencil on the right, with my velcocity tool set for the command click for the piano roll (each editor you can set 3 dif tools). All these are easily changable in the top right and will continue to follow which I ever tool I want them to be if I know going to continue my editing in a certain format. Now getting to your concerns.

* Left click once to create a note. The note created has the same duration as the last note you drew.

Pencil tool does exactly like you say with one click and keeping the same duration as last created/clicked

* Left click and drag on a note to move it in any direction.

yup - selector tool - i have mine set to go only left/right or up/down when i'm moving a note

* Left click and hold while creating a note to move it around in any direction.

pencil reacts differently in that when i hold down it changes the duration of the note which i actually find more helpful - why would i want to click somewhere where i don't want the note :/

* Right click to turn the cursor into a delete tool.

you could set it up for right click - or you could set it up for command click - which i actually would do if it wasn't for the velocity tool which gives me the ability to change velocity by clicking and drag on a note which find to be faster for my workflow - if i need to delete a note which isn't done as much as changing velocity then i'll just hit delete - it's really not that much longer to just hit delete with how often i do it

* Left click and drag the end of a note to resize.

again selector tool - resizes notes when on the end

logic has all the same functionality you ask for and more especially with the hyper editor and transform window. the transform window is extremely powerful in doing large edits in one click. for example, say you give a performance where 127 triggers a sample you don't want - and you did it a bunch through a long take. bring up the transform window - set up your maximum midi velocity for 126 and logic will take care of the rest for you. you can set up all kinds of parameters to be automated/fixed and you can even put objects into the arrange to affect hardware or software instruments.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...