Is a Good Sonic Musical Possible?

[OzGuy]

Sonic Underground is... not a good show. At all. It's a cringe-fest that tried to turn a hedgehog full of Blink-182-esque energy into Meat Loaf.

But when you think about it, a good Sonic musical should be a pushover! I mean, the music is Final Fantasy levels of consistent quality!

So, what's the answer? Covers of songs from the games?

[OzGuy]

Or something else?

[AngelCityOutlaw]

1 hour ago, OzGuy said:

Sonic Underground is... not a good show. At all. It's a cringe-fest 

I can't imagine a Sonic musical that wouldn't be a cringefest, tbh

[Garpocalypse]

If you're asking for some cringey sonic musicals....It's been done, 

 

 

 

 

[OzGuy]

Right. Well, those are kind of satirical, but what I'm asking is how to make a quality Sonic musical. Say... a musical take on the pre-SGW Archieverse?

And don't say Sonic Live in Sydney.

[Bowlerhat]

I'd say that a proper sonic musical would require a proper funding, which would require a proper audience. There are quite some sonic fans out there, but I don't know if there's enough sonic fans in a specific area that would pay money to attend a musical. I think that the closest you'd get is to make some kind of musicalesque audio thingy over the internet with lots of likeminded musicians. That'd even sound like a pretty nice idea. But to have an actual musical with actors and props and the whole gazwishmosh is probably not lucrative. 

[AngelCityOutlaw]

The real question here is "Why would anyone want this?"

[OzGuy]

Not a play! That's WAY too far!

What I meant was... maybe something like P&F... OK this is a lost cause.