DarkeSword

You make good points. What does everyone else think? EDIT: You know what? I DON'T GIVE A SHIT WHAT YOU GUYS THINK. I'M JUST GONNA MAKE A DECISION ON MY OWN!!!!! :-x I'm going to adjust the rules for this competition and say that session musicians/performers are allowed. If you have the resources to make that kind of thing happen, then you should be able to utilize those resources. Please keep in mind that musicians and performers should not be involved in the arrangement of your track. As always, I obviously have no way of enforcing this, so I'm asking you to be on your honor.

I have 11 entries so far. 2 hours left.

First place needs to clearly lead over second place, which is why it goes from 10 points to 8 points. Second place and third place should be competitive, which is why they're 8 and 7. Top three should lead over everyone else, which is why it goes from 7 to 5 in third to fourth place.

I've got 6 entries so far. Some really strong tracks this week. Remember folks, you've got until 6PM EDT today to get me your tracks. Don't miss the deadline! Let's try to get a full 14!

Remember folks, you have until 6PM EDT to submit your remixes to me. Don't forget to double-check your file names too. Team names, gauntlet themes, etc.

Me. I mean, I'm a moderator. I can monitor that kind of stuff.

Tallies and scores are updated.

I'll re-open up votes until 7PM EDT. Always make sure to check the first post for voting cut-off. Votes have been ending the day before mixes are due in my competitions for quite a while now.

Hey guys make sure when you're submitting your tracks, you get your team name right. It's "The Gobots" and "The Robot Museum," not just "Gobots" and "Robot Museum." Check against the scoreboard. Voting for round 1 is closed votes are tallied. Scores will be publicized and points will be awarded shortly.

The chord progression for Ice Cap Zone is wrong. At 3:56 you go up to an F instead of Eb.

There are no hard rules against revealing your track early; I can't stop someone from doing a live-stream or anything. I do, however, think it's best to keep your mix under wraps until the music is all posted together. I know all about Google Forms, but the ONLY way to guarantee that votes are legit are by keeping them on the forums. Someone could very easily dig up some old forum usernames of inactive people and ballot stuff that way. Given the things that have happened in the past with some competitions, I'm not interested in even dealing with the possibility of that. Plus I want people to sign up for the forums and get involved at OCR.

That second one just sounds like you being really grumpy. You probably need to lighten up.

Really not feeling it. The source connections are super tenuous and like Larry and Vig have pointed out, it doesn't really have anything interesting going on in terms of dynamics. NO

Loopy's an iOS application that allows you to set tempo and meter and then record loops of specific lengths. Once those loops are recorded they immediately play back and you can record more loops over top of them. The loops can then be turned on or off, which allows you to arrange the parts you've recorded. There won't be any special rounds between blocks. We are doing 3 blocks, back-to-back-to-back. The final round will probably be the same as last time: a two-week mixing stage with all team members collaborating, using their three Robot Master tracks and that round's gauntlet theme. Things can change though; my head is always swimming with ideas.

God Bless America. Anyway, I want to discuss another thing I'm seeing with novice mixers. A bit of a disclaimer: I'm going to talk now about my own approach to arrangement, and hopefully that will help you. I know that a lot of people can approach arrangement in their own way, and that's fine, but I want to talk about this because I want people to use these competitions as a learning experience. On with the show. Sometimes when I listen to entries from newbies, there's a sparseness there that really hurts the track. The issue ends up being that what I think of as the four basic elements of a song aren't present. Years ago I wrote an essay called "The Four Man Combo Approach to Arrangement" which explained how to make a full arrangement using the analogy of a four-man jazz combo. Because that analogy is not particularly relevant to everyone here, I'll paraphrase and be a bit more general. Generally speaking, there are four basic elements to a song: lead, accompaniment, bassline, percussion. When you have these four elements represented, you can achieve a basic fullness in your arrangement. Not coincidentally, basic NES music (like Mega Man songs!) follows this pattern. You've got your two pulse waves (lead and accompaniment), triangle (usually bass), and the noise and sample channels (usually percussion). The lead is obviously the melody; it's what everything else is built around. It generally sits in the middle or upper register. The bassline works with the percussion to establish the rhythmic "feel," but also lays down a foundation for the chords and harmonics structure of the piece; it generally sits in the lower register (i.e. bass). The percussion is there to establish the tempo and the general rhythmic "feel" of the track. You can do this without percussion, but more often than not this is the easiest way to do it. I'm talking about accompaniment separately because I feel like this is the one that people often overlook when starting out. Accompaniment can be a lot of things: sustained chords, syncopated chords, arpeggios, etc. The important thing about the accompaniment is that through the chords (and in tandem with the bassline), it gives the melody context. Accompaniment helps to establish the harmonic feel of your song; it lays out your chord progression and establishes key and tonality. These are really important things, especially when arranging melodic music like you find in Mega Man games. Now, when I talk about having the four basic elements of arrangement, I'm not telling you that you should only have four instruments in your track. You can have as many instruments as you want, but generally speaking, all of those instruments are going to fit into the specific roles. You'll have a couple of lead instruments trading on the melody or playing counter-melodies and embellishments, you'll have some strings or piano or brass or synths laying down your chords as accompaniment, and then you've got your bassline providing a solid foundation for everything to sit on, and then your percussion tracks set up the groove. So I want you newer guys to think about this when you're writing your track. Are you establishing the chords and using accompaniment effectively? Is your melody clear or is it fighting with the bassline because it's just too damn low? Did you forget about bassline and accompaniment altogether? Play your song back for your teammates and ask them if they can pick out the four elements. Hopefully you guys will take this to heart and we can start hearing some fuller, more balanced arrangements. Happy mixing.

No rules against it, but I personally am not a fan.

Part-writing in this piece is actually super simple, masked by the sound design. I'm in agreement with Larry and Vig. I feel like this arrangement doesn't have much going on with it, and it's playing it pretty safe. Counter-melody writing it's very interesting at all, and you've got some dissonance issues at 2:37. Sounds are not jiving. Needs work. NO (resub)

You've gotta be really careful about mixing sources that are very short and attempting to expand them a lot. It's very easy to veer off in the realm of "inspired by" rather than sticking to "an arrangement of." When I tackle a short source, I usually try to grab another theme from the game to fill things out melodically. I feel like there are significant sections of this piece that, while not sounding out of place stylistically in say, a Metroid Prime game, still strays too far from the actual source tune you're trying to arrange. I really like this piece (the arrangement and production are fantastic), but I feel like it could use a lot more actual Metroid material. I'm not sure if you're up for revisiting this track, but if you are, maybe poke around the Fusion soundtrack and see if there's any strong melodic themes you can pull into this piece. NO (resubmit)

Mixing's a little iffy but like I said in another vote on another mix earlier today, nothing that's a dealbreaker in my opinion. I didn't vote on the previous sub, so I'm coming in fresh. This arrangement is pretty killer. Nice variation. YES

Just heard a preview of the round 2 entry from the Rush Riders. I hope everyone's bringing their A game, because the Rush Riders are.

I love the mood here. I agree with Jesse that it's pretty simplistic, but I think that all of the parts come together to really knock out a great dance track. I'm groovin'. YES

Love the big drums. Really cool. Nice glitchy and syncopation stuff. It's like Jet Set Mario, spray-painting fire flowers on the side of Koopa's castle. Turbo drums might have been a bit much though. xD YES

Vocal mixing is a little iffy at points, but nothing is a dealbreaker. Great arrangement, nice variation for such a long piece. YES

Way too loud. You need to turn down the volume on EVERYTHING.

I'm not "dragging Nintendo" into the conversation. This is the Wii U thread. Talking about Nintendo is what's supposed to happen here. The fact that Nintendo does not provide the options to play games that fall under the full range of ratings (either through first party or by aggressively courting third-parties) is a failure and it lends to their image problem as a "kiddie" console. There's nothing wrong with those E and T games at all (I'm a huge fan), but Nintendo is always thinking about innovation in hardware and control systems, and those innovations could really do a lot in the realm of M-rated games that people like and want to play. Quite frankly, Nintendo is a games company, and they should be able to cater to a wider demographic. The fact that they don't is not something to just roll over and accept, or to be proud of. Oh also, just to be clear, I own and regularly play PC, WiiU, 360, PS3, 3DS, and Vita games. I also have a PS4 on pre-order. I know all about what everyone has to offer.