Leaderboard

@Dextastic Not clipping, but VCA CV feed through or you could also call it VCA clicking. Basically, to get the synth to behave the way I wanted to with that sound that click was just part of it unfortunately and it is basically impossible to remove after the fact lol.

Here's some of my thoughts, since i didn't get a chance to vote. Kat - Oh man this is pretty, i love the contrasting sections between the rock and the orchestral, that works perfectly. If i have to be honest, the drums in the first half could be mixed a bit better, but the rest was soo good. Really nicely done well done! Wassup Thunder - Jesus that scared me lol. The orchestration really turns it into more PRC than MnP, it's gone from a slow emotional tune, into a cinematic film cue. Again the orchestration is awesome, and works well, but it's very PRC not MnP. Great job! TheVodouQueen - The chords are pretty....this is a chord progression i dig, like a lot. The contrasting sections works like a charm too, the whole track is too pretty. The vocals for me were a mixed bag. I like the idea of integrating it, but i feel it works best without them, i'm more a fan of the instrumental. The overall instrumental is very pretty, especially the ending. Great job! APZX - This is also pretty, i am in love with the synth choices, soo good. It's a bit too much on the amount of instruments, i like the ending a lot, you could add that in halfway to make it more spaced out, and not as busy. But the idea was lovely, i really like this a lot. Great job! HoboKa - I don't think i've ever received a real HoboKa entrant in a long time lol. It's always a bonus haha, Dex even said it lol. I do love the choir though, it's a beautiful addition with the piano. I do think it's a very static arrangement, you could add more, and make it more than 2 instruments. Great arrangement though! Great job! Souperion - The strings are nicely integrated. I like how it balances between strings and winds, very well done. I also like the pause in the middle, it's a great breather. Overall really nice solid take on the source. It could stand to add more variety, in the addition of instruments, as well as expansion, but the idea was lovely. Great job here!

Good round

Haha, thanks for giving the feedback though. Even "questionable" feedback can help an artist get introspective to improve. I think it's great that there's so many entries.

EDIT 2 million OK. The real feedback that I want to convey was in the Results/Comments. All other attempts...just...didn't match up to what I really think. The problem is...I'm no good at this. It's getting hard to give quality feedback cuz things have picked up again and we're getting a lot of quality entries. So...it falls down to minor gripes and that's when the questionable feedback arises.....I'm sorry for all the updates/edits. I'm so derp X_X

Good round all! And no sweat, Hoboka, I get ya. I agree with a lot of feedback that I veered from the MnP style a bit much, so I'll focus in on that next round! I appreciate the feedback in this contest. I'm always trying to get my orchestral elements to sound more organic and full, along with improving my arrangements in general. Can't wait to see the next round!

Results Kat got 1st with 24 points. Wassup Thunder got 2nd with 20 points The Voduo Queen got 3rd with 17 points. APZX got 4th with 13 points. Kat please PM me with your source pick for Round 121*** (copy-pasta fixed) Comments Great round folks!! But...looking back, I gotta say that my feedback on Wassup Thunder's entry was pretty bad. I still stand by the scoring, but the feedback I gave was just...terrible. Production niggles aside, the Composition, it is VERY good and it is still within MnP's scope. So I failed there. Apologies man. X_X Souperion's Vote 1st: Kat's Winter's End. 2nd: Wassup Thunder's 3rd: APZX's. Thanks, sorry for the mishmash.

I tried to upload a second song, but that didn't work directly. However, I found a way to get a second song in. First I change the user name from the first song to another username. Then I upload the second song and after that I change the username from the first song back. So if anyone wants to submit a second song as well, please let me now in this thread (or by PM). If you post a download link I can upload it as well.

Honestly where I'm at now, I'm kind of...stuck. I'm like dude I went into a whole new direction, which I like, and I think I'm doing fine with, but I am just unsure how to get home exactly without just kinda...mailing it in. I'll keep working but right now what I have isn't too much different than what I last gave. Really, I'm just trying not to do too much. I'm playing this line between cool effects and atmosphere and sensory overload. That and it's like coming down from the mountains with the climax I just did haha. Anyway, I think I just need one last visit from the muse that got me here and I'll be able to take it home.