Not liking something as much as another person doesn't mean not liking it at all. I even said I would watch it again sometime.
SPOILER WARNING
And Lotd2242's reasons for finding it not his tastes are, quite frankly, valid. I found the way the motorbike came out of the Tumbler to be a reach. All the way through the movie until that point, I never had to go into any level of suspension of disbelief. But once I saw that bike pop out of the side, it popped that nice little bubble that had been there since the movie started. If Batman had instead salvaged parts from it and made the bike as a substitute later on, that would have not only been awesome as hell, but entirely plausible.
I know this is Batman and all, but since this series takes its realism and serious aspects to heart, this and a few other scenes were just a little too much. I can see Joker sticking bombs in people, I can see him wearing a nurse uniform to get into the hospital. That makes sense. He's crazy. But other parts juuuust creep over the line to overboard.
But yes, I think we can all agree that pencil trick was perhaps the single best part of the entire film.