Jump to content

OceansAndrew

Members
  • Posts

    6,960
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    12

Posts posted by OceansAndrew

  1. This doesn't waste any time establishing a great groove, and it transitions between sources pretty well, giving the different sections a nice feel. The real upside of having a solid group group of musicians come together to make a song like this is all in the details. All the small fills and personalized nuances bring it to life and give it it's own feel compared to the already well-produced originally. The solos are excellent, the pacing is great, and the sources meld well together.

    The one nitpick I have is that i'd like a little more clarity in production of the drums; a little less room mic and a little more close in the mix, but it's clearly a style choice and the track as a whole sizzles. More please!

    Yes

  2. im generally on board with the breakdown that Emu has; there is some cool changes going on, but it's a bit heavily skewed toward original material. I think adding more source

     

    Balancewise, the bass is lot boomy later on and needs to be adjusted. The mids sound like they need a bit more melody in them as well, the bell synth gets it done decently enough, but you could double that with an epiano to fill out some other frequencies.

     

    It shows promise and the production is close, but the main issue for me is the need for more dominant source throughout. Solid foundation is there though!

     

    No, please resubmit

  3. Cool and friendly source, I am digging it. 

     

    It sounds like the arrangement itself is fine if a bit repetitive, but the way the whole track is being filtered is really off-putting. Even though everything has very specific and deliberate filters applied to it, but none of them are lining up in a way to make the track sound balanced. The bass is being scooped out so there are no real low mids, the kick has all the attack removed without anything to fill that new space, and while I think it has a few monents where everything clicks during transitions and such, those moments are too sparse to make the track feel cohesive as a whole. 

    The overall feeling is positive, with a fun and upbeat melody, but the balance is very off, and the arrangement needs more development. I think some additional work on humanizing the sequencing, developing the mood as the track progresses, and a lot less filtering would be a step in the right direction. 

    No, please resubmit

  4. Really nice execution on your ideas here, it gels together really well. The opening bass filter and build sets up the tone for the whole song, which has a lot of great synth handoffs of what is doing lead duty. The rhythm of the backing parts subdivision keeps the track interesting throughout, and overall it is all clicking for me. Good showing!

    Yes

  5. I really like the brass additions to this and think it adds a good deal of character. The different section are solid, and there is a lot to like. The acoustic sections and the buildups after them were great. Solo was pretty good too.

    The guitar performance was fine but I do agree it felt sloppy in parts. 

    I do think the drums sound smashed and weak though, and plodding. PM me, i'll give you One Weird Production Trick that will make other producers HATE you. A local mom found it, and it will fix up this song easy.

    No, please resubmit

     

  6. This is definitely close; I think sidechaining the percussion with the bass and the rhodes would help give things the room they need, and would help things feel higher fidelity. The arrangement is solid, but I think the one change is what this needs to put it over. I definitely could see this getting some yes votes, but I think the "one weird trick" of sidechaining will have such a big impact on this that it's  worth a third submission to get it sounding amazing. If you want more details, hit me up via PM and I can give you specific compressor settings I think would work well.

     

    No, please resubmit

  7. I'll agree with the other judges in that this feels like a decent sketch but not a fully realized song. You did do a decent amount with a pretty minimal source, and you've got some skill, but it needs more polish. I'd take the advice of the other judges and run with it. :-)

     

    No, please resubmit

  8. 6 hours ago, theshaggyfreak said:

    Yay! Thanks OA! You are rock! I've been wanting to read these! They're actually written by a friend of mine. :)  I'll have to think hard about how I want to use that coupon too!

    ss2015.jpg

    cool, glad you like it, hit me up when you have a song request :-)

  9. i'm in - 

    pick 1: Dracula's Castle from SoTN https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_zB1HelWFNw

    pick 2: Theme of Simon from Super Castlevania 4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AKVmvVRXXCM

    pick 3: Legend of Dracula from Castlevania Adventure https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mbNR9Msoe2A&index=11&list=PL13D6E1504CB09657

    pick 4: Dracula's Cathedral from Castlevania Legends https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gLOFMe995T8

     

     

     

    EDIT: I didnt read the rules and 2 of my themes are no good. My bad

    DOUBLE EDIT: one is back in!

×
×
  • Create New...