Emunator   Judges ⚖️

4 days and no posts? Let's get this guy some feedback! First thing I notice is the intro just seems empty and doesn't contribute anything to the mix really. It's a totally different mood as the rest of the song, I'd definitely start from scratch with it. You've got some neat pitch bending ideas on your melody but the lead itself that you're using is a little underwhelming. There's a few good leads that fit the bill in the free Kore Player base sample packs that might suit your needs better here. The rest of the song is really short & basic and probably not suited for OCR because of its simplicity and lack of detail in either the ambiance or the arrangement, but it's enjoyable for what it's worth. Fun, sugary-sweet groove with some very subtle ambient effects make this a fun listen for a casual listener Not too shabby, way to break out of your comfort zone and try something new!

Yeah, this is sounding a lot fuller, very good work bringing all these instruments to life! I'm not really feeling the flute-sounding instrument at the end, though - it seems an odd choice to throw in for the last 10 seconds of the mix and sounds rather weak compared to the rest of your instrumental samples. All in all though, this is good I'd look for a suitable substitute for the flute at the end, maybe work on smoothing out the transition from the intro to the section with drums (it seems kind of rough as-is) and make any last touch-ups you see fit... and then seriously give some thought to submitting this. It's good

That's totally fine, you shouldn't expect yourself to be at OCR-level right off the bat. Most artists spend years and years trying to reach that level, so I'm glad that you're not discouraged from making more stuff. I'd chalk this up to a learning experience - it's not bad, but you've got lots of room to improve as well. So keep laying down the music and you'll work your way up there in due time Thanks for coming to the workshop forums, hopefully we were able to help give you some direction on what to work on with future mixes!

Yeeaaaahhh booiiii GET SOME!

Hey, sorry it took me so long to get back to you on this one! I've had a rough week and just haven't had the necessary time to do my workshop mod duties like normal Anyway, I'll have to echo the issues that Theophany and others brought up. This one takes a long time going places and overall the song feels very static. There's not a lot changing around, all of your instruments and synths remain in the same frequency range throughout most of the song with a few exceptions. To your credit though, your pads and ambient effects do help fill out the soundscape a lot, and there's a couple of verses that sound like you did a better job of filling out the space. I would recommend changing up the instruments you've got playing the main melody line though - the piano sample that you've got would fare better as a supporting instrument because it's just not a strong enough sample to carry the song on its own. Search around for a while or mess with some synth creator programs to see what you could come up with, I bet you'd be surprised at what you can find with minimal effort Having some different sounds pop in from time to time would really improve this mix. Either that, or try and find a more expressive, higher-quality piano sample, perhaps? I'm personally not feeling the acoustic bass, I'd like to see what you could do with a more electronic-sounding bass instrment, it might mesh with the rest of your instruments better. I'd like to hear an update on this before I critique it further - you've got a wonderful source tune and some nice effects going for you, but this needs some work to make it more dynamic, less repetitive, and ultimately bring it up to the bar it deserves to be at Keep at it!

First thing I notice right off the bat is the incredibly thin piano. It sounds almost too drowned in fx and reverb for its own good I guess that might be intentional but I think you went overboard. And if it's just a weak sample problem, I'd recommend looking into that as well. Past that though, this is a lot more enjoyable. The vocals are mixed in pretty nicely but I think they could use a bit of filtering so it fits in better with the electronic soundscape. The beat/synth work is pretty tight, although sometimes it drowns out the vocals and makes them unintelligible from a lyrical standpoint. Not that they don't sound cool even if you can't understand the lyrics, but if you're going for making them understandable I'd take that into consideration. Conversely, I think the final "dreams" vocal clip is too loud and the piano outro is too quiet, so check your levels around there. You've got some nice arrangement chops and your girlfriend has a great singing voice for this style

Just a quick update, Children of the Monkey Machine has dropped his tracks, but joining the project now is Matt Drouin! Welcome! I've gotten a few confirmations from artists who are indeed working on their tracks, and heard a really wonderful D&B WIP from Sole Signal for Rocket Run! Hope to hear lots of stuff flowing in soon, 'cause the deadline is in 2 weeks! If you need an extension, contact me sooner rather than later! Also, the first project track to get submitted to the panel got accepted today Grats to GSlicer and The Scarborough Joker for getting "Water Warped" past the judges!

Your production seems very polished, and this is a neat groove. I'd have liked to hear you rely a bit less on the same sounds for the whole song (although the delayed synths were pretty cool!) and mix it up a bit more, but for what it's worth it's an enjoyable listen You've clearly got the chops to make some fantastic remixes, you've already proven that with your posted mix. Do more stuff like this, but take the arrangement up a notch and try not to rely on the same loops so much, and you'll be golden!

I was gonna hold off and leave a long, insightful piece of feedback on this mix because I thought it had potential and was worth working on (plus you used a wonderful source tune!) but I'm thinking Liz and Sir Snooze really nailed it completely. The ambiance is relatively well done, but your synths are pretty generic and don't complement each other or the soundscape you've crafted with the pads. I also somewhat agree with the comment on the drums. They seem like they're a bit too loud and harshly mixed for this kind of song - I'm not saying you need to stick with the feel of the original, but given the rest of the sounds you used I think the drums need to be brought down a bit in order to mesh well with everything else. Basically, Liz covered it all very adeptly and in more words than I could have used You'd be right to listen to her advice as well as some of what Sir Snooze added, as well. You've got an interesting expansion on the original but it's got some issues and sound choices that need to be ironed out. Good luck!

Hey, this is pretty cool But yeah, really short as well. The organ sounds wonderful and the writing for it is equally enjoyable. The lick from :09-:14 is really slick! I feel like the piano isn't packing as much punch as it should be, it kinda pales in comparison to the strength of the organ. The notes themselves could use a bit of sustain too, I think. If this is finished, fair enough. But I'd love to hear this expanded a bit and the production polished, I think it might stand a chance against the OCR panel with a bit of work

This is badass.

Try to keep all posts about this WIP to one thread in the future instead of making multiple ones. Thanks I'll give you some more feedback once you expand this and polish it, but you really need to pan your bass center. It's really hard to listen to this song and give you substantial critiques when the bass is so distracting

Well, in his defense, I have gotten a handful of island/reggae-themed WIPs so far I forgot to mention this earlier, welcome TenchuX to the project, he'll be doing an ethnic/electronic fusion for Cranky's Dojo. He's only showed me a short WIP but it's pretty solid-sounding so far

Kill the dissenter!

Tough shit!

I find it really hard to believe that you all weren't able to implement a MIDI rip feature with 90% of the site funds. It can't be that hard

THIS PROJECT IS CANCELED! I, for one, welcome our new Remixinator overlords.

Wow, this is a really unique concept, way to step outside of the box Sub this now!

The Vagrance brings up a pretty good point, when you're going to go gritty with a song you need to break it up so it doesn't wear on the listener. A lot of the effects you've got going are really cool, and I'm especially loving the drumwork. But it's too relentless for my tastes. Very cool processing, effects, and some brilliant percussion though. Do something different with the arrangement a few times to chunk up the song and you've got yourself a remix that could definitely pass through the panel. Keep at it!