Wow, this topic really took off! I'm glad I could promote such philosophical discussion!
I too noticed that his style seemed to emulate Yahtzee, and contained an unnecessary amount of swearing. But can we really tell if he was just speaking his mind, or if this was truly his intention?
What I most appreciated about his rant was when he attacked sports games and their horrible lack of depth and creativity. I've always wondered, should sports titles even be considered games? After all, aren't games supposed to give you a world where the impossible is possible? Fantastic worlds, original characters, and stuff like that? I can throw a football in real life. Why do I need to play a game where I can do the same thing? But can I shoot futuristic aliens in real life? No, and I never will be able to. Videogames let me do that.
It really makes me wonder whether sports games are necessary, period.