arrrrr... can't find em. =(
I was going to say that this reminds me of two eerily similar comp ideas from a while ago, but I guess those threads were deleted and I dunno if they're archived somewhere.
I don't remember the exact words/description from each comp because I didn't participate in either, but from the top of my head:
1. The first one envisioned us, the remixer, being put into the pilot seat of the composer at the time the original source was created and the Comp guidelines was to make an 'original' song to replace the source, but using the same mindset that the composer had for said source. (ex., I take on the Super Metroid theme and replace it with a Buckethead Kaleidoscalp type original arrangement, since that is how I would interpret the feel of the Super Metroid theme from my perspective).
2. The other one was almost entirely word-for-word similar to what you stated with this comp idea (at least, according to my memory) in that it requested a similar conservative approach with ratio interpretation and shiz like that.
I'll pm you more in person, Hobo, if needed since you know how we roll , but I personally see nothing wrong with this comp idea. True, it will be hard for musicians like me who tend to gravitate towards the more 'liberal' side, but I think 'conservative' and 'liberal' are terms which are very nebulous in some cases. Each of those examples Timaeus listed are spot on demonstrations of arrangements which still have that essential feel of the song without deviating too much; I'd even add PirateCrab's recent Mythic Mist arrangement to that list because all though it is slightly more aggressive and rock-oriented I feel like it still has the core musical themes and feelings/vibes from the original (the mix between funk and playful creepy or whatever).
and as long as OCR's been around it's still a bit weird to me about how this 'issue' always comes up: https://www.facebook.com/notes/overclocked-remix/is-it-just-me-or-does-ocremix-sound-like-nothing-but-a-bunch-of-elitist-musician/10153100529660585
There are PLENTY of 'conservative' arrangements to go around, I just think that in more recent times (especially with projects) it has become natural for the community as a whole to veer towards more interpretation.
Even though musically this is very conservative (by my tastes at least) would this be this kosher with you?
By my book a conservative remix is one where an average joe who heard the original source would be able to easily pick it out in a remix and the 'feel' of the original is still obvious (a sad song from a sad part of a game is remixed with heavier electronic sounds but still sounds sad), whereas a distinctively liberal remix would be more like, in my opinion, The Katamari Forever and some stuff from the Sonic Generations soundtracks (a lot of the remixes are straightforward but some of them are fresh takes and re-interpretations of the originals).
_________
that's long enough, so I'll just pm you any other things that come to mind. =)
In a nutshell, I can get behind this, I just think that the whole 'conservative or liberal' terminology is mostly based on perspective. It's usually not genre switch ups or mood changes that make a song become liberal, in my opinion. It's more along the lines of changing chord progressions, inverting some of the melody, blah blah, etc..... fancy shiz like that.
just don't stress too hard about the ratio thing... when we start having to pull out the Larry stopwatch shiz starts getting mad complicated.
EDIT: tl;dr a peppy, bubbly j-pop remix of a super dark Assassin's Creed track would clearly not work with this comp, whereas just changing the relative key from 'minor' to 'major' or adjusting the tempo a little bit, etc. stuff like that should be fine, in my opinion.