DarkeSword   Administrators 🎮

I would rather just not restrict participants anymore.

If an image stretches a page, post a link instead. Post edited.

There were some issues that Capcom's legal department had with the competition (specifically our OC ReMixers only restriction), so that's why they went with an open submission format. We won't be sending any music to Capcom on anyone's behalf; you'll be responsible for sending them your music through that form. For my part, I want to apologize. When Capcom contacted us about music, Larry and I decided that whatever we'd be sending them, we'd need to have a baseline for quality, and the simplest way to do that was to limit the competition to OC ReMixers. No hate on newbies, but a lot of the time in these competitions, the newbie tracks don't cut it. If we'd known that Capcom just wanted basically everyone to send them anything and everything, we wouldn't have restricted it. We just had some miscommunication, which resulted in Capcom's decision to go ahead with this. I personally like running these competitions and encouraging newbies involved because it's a good way to develop skills. Future competitions by me won't ever have an "OC ReMixer-only" restriction. You're assuming a lot of bad shit about Capcom, which isn't really warranted. I mean, honestly, "get drunk and play your music?" Come on. The "celebration activities" they're talking about are things they're going to be doing with the fanbase to celebrate SF's 25th anniversary. If you don't want to submit your music because you disagree with what is a pretty standard licensing agreement for derivative works, that's fine, but please don't sit there and badmouth the community guys over at Capcom. They're good dudes and they're not out to screw anyone over. Anyway that's all I'm going to say about that, and that's all I want to see about that in the thread. Let's just get back to discussing the competition itself.

Yeah. Needs vocals. Instrumental alone isn't cutting it; not enough overt source usage. Chord progression isn't even from the original. Needs way more actual VGM material and something going on besides just a beat. NO

Yeah Larry pretty much sums it up. Too repetitive; not enough material to justify the length. It just goes and goes with the same thing over again. Nice concept but needs more. NO

I don't find any issue with the synths at all. I like the interplay between rock and electronic. Some interesting mixing choices but nothing egregious as far as I'm concerned. Rocks out pretty well, good take on the source. YES

I like it, it's super chill. Nice flow. Reminds me of TheWingless when it starts out. Personally not a fan of the percussion. Sticks out a bit too much and the dryness contrasts poorly with the rest of the piece, especially the hihats; the rhythms don't really gel with the rest of the piece. Plus it feels like they go on autopilot around 2:55. Will probably be in the minority but the drums are a dealbreaker for me in this case. NO (resub)

There is absolutely no truth in this whatsoever.

Was it a good title? I wasn't reading it.

It's fine because she's looking for something specific.

Gonna echo comments about the drums. They're huge and overcompressed and taking up all the space. Really messy. Arrangement is conservative, but guitar work is good. Needs to be mixed better. NO

fixed. Make sure you use Ryu's theme, not Oni. Sorry about that.

oh goddamnit

If people are not going to express interest or ask questions in a respectful way, they should not post. Carry on.

The synth flying all over the place is excessive, indulgent, aimless, and distracting. Piano starts doing the same thing later on in the piece and it's extremely mechanical. Not really feeling this piece at all. Other Js outlined issues with drums and balance, so I'm not going to rehash there. Main offender for me is overdone 'soloing.' NO

Moved to recruit and collab. Not really offtopic.

You guys need to lay off and just wait for SuperiorX to post the thread. I'm going to lock this thread. Just wait for Saturday.

Home from PAX. Everything is updated. Check first post for new music.

At pax east. Can't tally votes. Go by sectorz tallies. Updates later

Fairly enjoyable but some of the choices in your percussion are strange. There's a lot of machine-gunning kick and snare which distracts quite a bit; too much attention being drawn to the percussion at times. I guess it's a stylistic thing? Percussion doesn't really lock into the rest of the piece. Not a dealbreaker though. Sounds are good and it's a nice arrangement. YES (borderline)

Next month.

If I gambled, I'd take that bet and you'd owe me 5 dollars. It's hilarious and quite honestly mind-boggling that people keep thinking this. Why on Earth would they go back to how things were before? What about it makes you think that this is all temporary? The launch of the New 52 was massively successful for them and the entire DC Universe is much fresher and not bogged down by decades of continuity. There's a cohesiveness throughout all of the titles, and the way they've organized their different lines of comics (The Edge, The Dark, Young Justice, etc.) makes everything much easier to keep track of. Let's not even forget the fact that so much of what they're putting out right now is just so incredibly good.

I use a website that randomizes lists.

I can help you with bracket setup.