djpretzel Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 What did you think? Post your opinion of this ReMix. Quote
CrusaderX4 Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 I was originally a big fan of this piece while it was a WIP, though it was noticably synth at that point. I'm glad to see that the piece kept its generally frantic tempo with its calmer interludes. Overall, this is an excellent companion to the original that reminds me a bit of something that Noir might do, though the classical piano style definitely does not carry through the whole piece. Props to Nex for an amazing display of skill on the keys; I wouldn't have imagined too many people would be able to keep up the frantic tempo in spots like those around 2:00 that came easily with the synth in lightwarmth's WIP. Excellent remix. Quote
Uboichi2 Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 The piano maybe doesn't sound that good, but the arrangement more than makes up for this! Quote
HershDawg Posted August 29, 2004 Posted August 29, 2004 good job for the first remix of FF9's Dark Messenger song. Nice part where you added in a little of Kuja's theme. overall good mix i rate it a 8/10. Quote
tgfoo Posted August 30, 2004 Posted August 30, 2004 YAY!! Another good piano mix. This is a good arrangement by lightwarmth and some good playing by Nex. You guys make a great combo. Quote
underthesun Posted August 30, 2004 Posted August 30, 2004 I'd just like to mention that this song has been on repeat for the past few hours.. This really is.. well.. new. in the sense of style. Kudos to you two =) Quote
Random Fox Thought Posted August 30, 2004 Posted August 30, 2004 This is...wow. I'm always a fan of individuals who can do two things -- play the piano with a fast pace while maintaining a good sound/rhythym and interpret a song with many different instruments into a single piano solo. This does both of them nicely, what starts off as a normal piece quickly changes into what sounds almost like a slightly jazzy rendition of the moonlight sonata (act 3). I have a deep respect for people who play the piano so well -- this is obviously a good demonstration of playing the piano that well. Quote
Fieari Posted August 30, 2004 Posted August 30, 2004 This is quite awesome indeed. This is a style of piano I don't think I've ever heard before, mixing the rapid heart pounding driving sections in with the softer smoother gentler sections. I have but one complaint, and that is that I had to turn my speakers up a considerable amount in order to hear this mix. A little bit of extra volume would have been welcome, and perhaps just the tiniest bit of extra fidelity. Other than that, I'm in love with this piece. It just does everything so well! Quote
BlueEnvy Posted August 31, 2004 Posted August 31, 2004 I have a little bit of criticism to add to the reviews on this pretty well done arrangement. First of all, the piano has too much reverb, making many of the fast sections muddled together. Second, there isnt enough contrast between the melody and the counterparts/bass parts. The melody needs to be louder, and it seems that everything is mixed a little low, which makes it harder to distinguish the differences in volume. In comparison with the original, this does a pretty good job of taking it and transforming it into a piano piece, while keeping a consistent style. I think I actually prefer this piano arrangement over the original Nice job lightwarmth and Nex. Blue Edit: Something I forgot to add: the articulation sounds all the same to me...thats what you get using a keyboard and a piano sample but oh well Quote
Hogulus Posted August 31, 2004 Posted August 31, 2004 Love it so much, though you could have made it a little louder. Oh, and I know you're getting a lot of emails along the same vein as this, but: sheet music plz. Quote
lightwarmth Posted September 1, 2004 Posted September 1, 2004 www.sibelius.com - d/l sibelius scorch (free) www.squaresound.com - sheet music section, the arrangement sheets are there. Enjoy! thanks all for the reviews! Quote
Nex Posted September 1, 2004 Posted September 1, 2004 www.sibelius.com - d/l sibelius scorch (free)www.squaresound.com - sheet music section, the arrangement sheets are there. Enjoy! thanks all for the reviews! Yup yup. Thanks everyone for the reviews. You guys rock! PS. Lightwarmth, you should show SquareSound this recording in the 'FF9 > Piano Recordings' section Quote
Darangen Posted September 8, 2004 Posted September 8, 2004 I guess I'm the only one, but... I didn't enjoy this too much. It's a decent arrangement, played well if it wasn't sequenced, and not all that bad. However, to me it sounded like someone banging on a piano faster than they should, just trying to show off some of their speed/skill instead of making a pleasant sounding arrangement. I don't mean make a pleasant and peaceful arrangement of Dark Messenger, but something a little more pleasant to the ears instead of being reminded of a 9 year old banging on a piano. So my opinion: Too fast, too hard. Try easing up on those keys and playing with emotion instead of skill. 7/10 Quote
pixlz Posted September 8, 2004 Posted September 8, 2004 honestly didn't care for this remix all that much. i can't place what it is. i think its the fact it sounds like its being fast just to be fast. a few of the fast to slow transitions work and start to develop emotion behind the music..... but definitely not the developing of emotion everywhere and thusly falters a little in my book. gave it two listens through too. technically good, emotionally flat. have to say though, like it or not, kudos to anyone who can actually play that fast. Quote
Sam Ascher-Weiss Posted September 8, 2004 Posted September 8, 2004 have to say though, like it or not, kudos to anyone who can actually play that fast. This is not that fast. The only moderately difficult part of this arrangement is toward then end when you have to reach out with both pinkeys repeatedly. That requires swift wrist movement, however that is a skill that is quite easily mastered. There is definitely alot to like in this piece, however the technical skill needed to play it is not much of a selling point Quote
pixlz Posted September 8, 2004 Posted September 8, 2004 have to say though, like it or not, kudos to anyone who can actually play that fast. This is not that fast. The only moderately difficult part of this arrangement is toward then end when you have to reach out with both pinkeys repeatedly. That requires swift wrist movement, however that is a skill that is quite easily mastered. There is definitely alot to like in this piece, however the technical skill needed to play it is not much of a selling point mebbie it just sounds fast to me cause of the whole, me not being able to play. well steal the compliment from my post then why dontcha. =P Quote
BlueEnvy Posted September 10, 2004 Posted September 10, 2004 I guess I'm the only one, but...I didn't enjoy this too much. It's a decent arrangement, played well if it wasn't sequenced, and not all that bad. However, to me it sounded like someone banging on a piano faster than they should, just trying to show off some of their speed/skill instead of making a pleasant sounding arrangement. I don't mean make a pleasant and peaceful arrangement of Dark Messenger, but something a little more pleasant to the ears instead of being reminded of a 9 year old banging on a piano. So my opinion: Too fast, too hard. Try easing up on those keys and playing with emotion instead of skill. 7/10 It does lack emotion, but part of that could've been due to the sample's articulation. I think the sample is partly responsible for making it sound so bangy. Quote
Lord_Syruss_Khalai Posted September 17, 2004 Posted September 17, 2004 I think this is a great piece. I play the piano, and I only have a few problems. One was mentioned, and thats that it seems like the person playing this had their "foot on the pedal" a little to much. It makes for a great effect, but parts of it do run together. As far as a contrast between the lower and higher notes, I didn't really have a problem defferenciating between the two. Also, as far as it being fast, one thing that piano players will do so that the song doesn't sond monotonous is to speed up parts and slow down other parts. This song could be played all at the same speed, but then it would be repititious. Varying the play speed is a way to make one part stand apart from another, even if they are the same sequence of notes. And yeah, it was pretty soft, but it's not like that isn't easily remedied. Anyways, I'd have to give this remix a 9 out of 10. It's worth listening to many times. ~Lord Syruss Khalai Quote
FinalGamer Posted February 17, 2005 Posted February 17, 2005 To do this song in piano was a good idea. The tune is set very well and the pace works great into the atmosphere. 8/10 Quote
Bummer Posted September 22, 2005 Posted September 22, 2005 To be dark messenger, which has a very high tempo, this remix is good. Quote
SakakiAzu Posted November 12, 2005 Posted November 12, 2005 SUPERSPEED!!!!!! Very nice.... I liked how its in piano.... It works well... 9.5/10 Quote
willow-whisp Posted March 3, 2006 Posted March 3, 2006 This is a mix that deserves more props that it has thus far! I haven't got a lick of musical talent in me so I can't offer you constructive crits. I can only say that I have passed this song along to friends and find it tremendously inspiring. I really hope to hear more from you! Quote
isthan Posted September 30, 2006 Posted September 30, 2006 Piano's sound is very nice here. The speed isn't a problem to me, in fact I especially like that crazy fast part at the beginning. And with the original melody as it is, it's impossible to fail. 9/10. Quote
Lucentas Posted March 6, 2009 Posted March 6, 2009 Now this is a jammin' tune. I absolutely love the crazy piano work, amazing job. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.