All Activity
- Today
-
*NO* Clock Tower "When the Bell Tolls One"
Chimpazilla replied to Liontamer's topic in Judges Decisions
Cool original, and cool track but I agree with my fellow Js that the source song isn't nearly recognizable enough for OCR. The arrangement is cool but the sections get repetitive with the same instruments and patterns over and over. The mix is super low-heavy and the master is quite loud, I think the low end could be a bit better controlled so you have a little more headroom to work with and then there's no need to push the limiter so hard. But generally, this is a cool listen! Just not enough source for OCR. For OCR, the source song would need to be very easily identifiable, and you could do all kinds of original things over the top of it, that is a great remix strategy for such a simple and repetitive source. NO -
Rise of the Triad - Havana Smooth Remix
-
Interesting source to cover, it doesn't that have much material but a neat atmosphere. I think prophetik above did a good job describing each section so I won't expand much there. I generally agree with his take on source usage, your track is taking musical ideas similar to the original, like 3 note arpeggios on several sections making "melodies" with the highest note of the arpeggio, but at no point plays the source in a way that anyone would clearly pinpoint it being a cover. For example, on the intro you're doing a 3-2-1 "melody" on F minor while the source does 5-6-4 on D minor (plus the 3-4-2 flourish to end each phrase), you then change the "melody" to a different one that still doesn't clearly echo the source. The synth arpeggio at 1:08 is the closest to the source since at least it has the 5-6 interaction, but it's a minor part of the track so even if it counted as "source usage" we'd be left with an arrangement that's largely "original". As an aside, on the 2:03 you're layering a synth playing a melody on C# minor over the F minor arrangement and it doesn't really sound good to my ears. I'm assuming you're doing this contrast intentionally but it doesn't land well IMO. K, so on arrangement. First, this isn't fit for OCR on its current form as its not really an identifiable cover of the source. It'd definitely need retooling on that side to clear our submission standards. Besides from that I think the arrangement's quite good, sections are well constructed and it flows well. I do agree with proph that it's fairly repetitive though, there's potential to add some extra touches on repeats to make each section feel unique. I don't have many notes on production, I think most elements sound good and are easy to hear in the soundscape. Only instrument I felt could use some extra work are the low strings, it lacks some clarity that could be achieved with more attack on the sample or maybe layering an staccato string playing the same lines. Overall, I think this is a solid arrangement with good production. However, it feels more like an original song than a clear cover of the source, which disqualifies it for OCR. If you intend to resubmit it you'd need to rework the arrangement to make the source usage more clear. It'll be challenging with a source like this but there's elements that could be highlighted and expanded even on such a short track (the 5-6-4 "melody", the 3-4-2 flourish at the end of each phrase, the #7 that gives the arpeggio a harmonic minor feel). For now though, the vote is: NO
- Yesterday
-
Davtronics joined the community
-
*NO* Half-Life: Episode 1 "Status: Hired"
Hemophiliac replied to prophetik music's topic in Judges Decisions
This feels and sounds like a more modernized version of the original source. The ability to recreate all of that from scratch is impressive. However, there is a lot of similarity to the original source making this very conservative. Well, that's not what we're looking for in arrangements. I'd like to see more development of the source into more of your own interpretation. Right now this is very close to a cover. Even stepping away for a contrasting section that changes up the texture for a bit would be a good way to vary it up some. Give us more things like the synth guitar at 1:43 and the final 15 seconds of the piece. This is where I see sigtau coming through and less of the original, give us more sigtau! The production is mostly fine as I didn't catch anything egregious standing out to me. On that front I felt like the synth bass was weak and could support the piece more, but this by itself was not a dealbreaker. The drop at 1:57 into the transition was cool! The main issue is the similarity of arrangement to the source and how conservative it is. I could see this developing into more, but as of right now it's not ready. NO -
I was browsing through YouTube videos that have been salvaged - meaning they were saved before that user was either terminated or they closed their YT account. One day, I stumbled upon this: https://archive.org/details/mmd-story-vocaloid-story-vocaloid-drama-part-2/%5BMMD+Story%5DVocaloid+Story+Vocaloid+DRAMA%5BPART+6_LAST+PART%5D.mp4 If you can help me identify the names of all the songs and BGM tracks used in all these videos, please do, I have a serious migraine after finally seeking my long lost gold nugget: Sara's Theme/Fate - Breath Of Fire 1 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fXVigQZCTPY I especially need to know the name of the song and version type used during the sequence where the three grieve over Neru's death. Again, AHA music, Siri, Shazam, and SoundCloud can only aid in so much. I even tested them on a track like In The Darkness Lies OC Remix - Banjo Kazooie, and they were all unable to identify the track. So, this is where human sleuthing is needed. These are all going to help me learn how these types of tracks are utilized in these types of scenarios. Extra note: Naruto is both an anime and a video game franchise, so this is why I added both video game and anime BGM.
- Last week
-
I'll use my words, since no one else will! BACKED, Sam! I have pretty much all your stuff. Metroid Cinematica & Recharged, Chrono Cinematica, actually listened to Xeno Cross this week (I would also back a WHOLE-ASS 10 disc album of that idea BTW). But I've always adored the Mana soundtracks, especially Kikuta's SD2 and 3. I hope you get this off the ground, and I'm so looking forward to it!
-
MegaMixtape started following Banner Art Breakdown Stream
-
untilJoin us for another banner art breakdown with Lauren the Flute, banner artist for Dwelling of Duels' Koji Kondo Month! Remember to tune in on the DoD Twitch channel.
-
derezr reacted to an 8Track: MY LITTLE PONY FRIENDSHIP IS MAGIC
-
*NO* Tyrian 2000 "Q is the letter, Q is the composition"
Hemophiliac replied to prophetik music's topic in Judges Decisions
First off I wanted to say that I think there's a cool idea here. Translating this to piano and cello to start feels like a no-brainer, but the idea works very well. When the other parts come in (bass, drums, strings, and guitar) at 1:15 this feels more fleshed out as a potential idea for a track. The guitar in particular is the best sounding element in this track with reverb and delay on it, and has a fitting tone for the track. Where this falls is the execution of production and the closeness to the original source tune. Adding the additional band parts is a step in the right direction, but it's still just the same melody and structure around that. More expansion and development of that idea and with more of your own ideas is the way to go. Production/sequencing leaves us with something much to be desired. We're really lacking the human feel here. It's all ice-cold perfectly sequenced with repeated velocities in the piano with line-locked rigid timing early in the piece. Humans don't play the exact same dynamic/velocity from note to note. There will always be miniscule differences between them. The timing won't fall exactly on the beat every single time. The cello sample in particular sounds very low quality and cuts off suddenly when it's done at 0:41. Almost feels like there's no reverb on the piano or cello to help with realism. Drum fill on the toms at 1:41 is awkwardly out of time. There's over a minute of silence at the end. Please double check your submission before sending it in next time. Once again, would love to see further development of your own ideas and expansion upon the source and not just a conservative arrangement on new instruments. The production should also be looked at for more realism with attention paid to humanization of the parts. It's a cool vibe, but not ready for OCR. NO -
Fiddledo joined the community
-
David Kiraeth changed their profile photo
-
timaeus222 reacted to a post in a topic: HAPPY 25th BIRTHDAY, OC ReMix!
-
timaeus222 reacted to a post in a topic: HAPPY 25th BIRTHDAY, OC ReMix!
-
timaeus222 reacted to a post in a topic: HAPPY 25th BIRTHDAY, OC ReMix!
-
What are you listening to?
Rapidkirby3k replied to PassivePretentiousness's topic in General Discussion
🛠🔮⚙️ -
Ridiculously Garrett reacted to a post in a topic: Smash 64 - Yoshi's Island Sambatronic
-
Master Mi reacted to a post in a topic: Just found some fresh 'n' fiery Lufia 2 remixes
-
Óscar Élan started following Ghosts 'N Goblins (Graveyard theme)
-
hi! I’ve just finished my orchestral remake of Graveyard from Ghosts ’n Goblins, mainly based on the PSP version, and I hope you enjoy it.
-
DarkeSword reacted to an event: Dwelling of Duels: Koji Kondo Month
-
Óscar Élan joined the community
-
iyonUK joined the community
-
Just found some fresh 'n' fiery Lufia 2 remixes
Atomicfog replied to Master Mi's topic in General Discussion
Definitely inspired. Thank you so much for sharing those. They seem like they would fit right in here. -
What are you listening to?
NovemberRhythm replied to PassivePretentiousness's topic in General Discussion
-
untilAugust is Koji Kondo Month! All video game songs that are composed by Koji Kondo are eligible! Since there are a number of games where Koji Kondo did some (but not all) of the songs, check out this link for the definitive answer on what qualifies https://nintendo.fandom.com/wiki/Koji_Kondo The submission deadline is Thursday, August 28, 2025 8:00 PM This month's banner art is by LaurenTheFlute!! Check out her BlueSky and Twitch!! https://bsky.app/profile/laurentheflute.bsky.social https://www.twitch.tv/LaurentheFlute If you have any questions regarding if a game fits this theme, message us on the DoD Discord server! Upload your submission for the month using our Submission form! Dwelling of Duels entry rules: Main Entries Alternate Entries Listening Party Check out the entries LIVE over at the Dwelling of Duels Twitch on Friday, August 29, 2025 8:00 PM.
-
untilIt's Koji Kondo Month! at Dwelling of Duels! Check out the entries LIVE over at the Dwelling of Duels Twitch on Friday, August 29, 2025 8:00 PM And don't forget to vote at the Dwelling of Duels website.
-
untilIt's WiiU Wiik at Dwelling of Duels! Check out the entries LIVE over at the Dwelling of Duels Twitch on Saturday, August 9, 2025 12:30 AM And don't forget to vote at the Dwelling of Duels website.
-
wokenav joined the community
- Earlier
-
Mega Man Zero 4 - Falling Down Remix
-
annehenson21 joined the community
-
Okay, the title is weird, I know. I don't know if many here know this show and if they hate it or not. But each of these songs reminds me of the six main ponies (manesix). Since I need to choose two more remixes, I chose two more that remind me of the show. XD From top to bottom, it would look like this: Twilight Sparckle, Rarity, Applejack, Pinkie Pie, Rainbow Dash, Fluttershy, and the other two remixes are the bonus songs that remind me of something from the show.
-
I've been streaming footage of the Aomori Nebuta Festival this week while listening to Japanese pop music and Japanese-style VGM, which inspired me to create this 8Track. These are just some of my favorite Japanese-style remixes, whether it's because I love their use of Japanese instruments, use of Japanese language, or just because they remind me of some of my favorite Japanese pop music.
-
Smash 64 - Yoshi's Island Sambatronic
Tex replied to Ridiculously Garrett's topic in Post Your Game ReMixes!
Wow, I like it a lot! You really chose a fitting genre for this, haha. Love your ensemble, too, especially the minimoog-ish synths. -
OCRA-0021 - THE ANSWER - Armored Core Tribute Album -
JagerBaBomb replied to djpretzel's topic in Album Reviews & Comments
So! 2025. A lot has happened since this was released. The whole world knows Armored Core now. I've gone through and played all the games again. And this album? Still slaps. Would love to hear some takes on the new gen, but I'm glad this is still here. -
*NO* Clock Tower "When the Bell Tolls One"
prophetik music replied to Liontamer's topic in Judges Decisions
really neat original. that short synth tone is really unique. opens with some bells and ambient synths. it doesn't sound like most of the things being played are the original, but rather following a similar structure. the beat comes in at 0:28, and the strings that eventually come in also are outlining a descending pattern that isn't the same notes or particularly close to the original. same with the eventual synth arp. beat drops around 1:22 for a bit, but comes back unchanged. there's a recap of what just happened, and the opening bells come in too, but still no source. we get something that's again reminiscent of the original at 2:03, but all that includes is movement from the 5 to the b6 and b7 - none of the 5 b6 4 5 pattern that permeates the original, and also none of the little 7-8 lick that stands out in the original as well. we get another break at 2:44 with some choral elements, but the same taiko and synth elements in the background are still there. we do get some more unique strings after this when the same beat comes back in again, but nothing from the original. there's a fun stutter effect in the strings near the end, and then it's done with the arps fading out (over a very long time, this probably should be shortened by half if not more). unfortunately this doesn't really appear to be a remix of the Cradle Under the Star theme, but rather something inspired by it or reminiscent of it. there's no actual original material that i can hear in the track you've submitted. so that's a dealbreaker right there. separately, it's really obvious in here where you copy/paste each individual element's block of material - the synth does the same thing every time it shows up, the beat is the same, the taiko element is the same, etc. even the fake scream transition sfx is used repeatedly. that much repetition becomes really noticeable really quickly when you listen to something more than once. spending the extra time to make each entrance of an instrument unique is absolutely worth it. if this was a complete arrangement of the original, i'd probably still reject it due to how muddy and overly dense the representation is, and how much repetition is used. i think that the original's neat and there's definitely legs for this style of arrangement. trimming the fat and making it more clearly related to the original will definitely help craft a better overall product. NO